54.5 F
New Haven
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
- Advertisement -spot_img

Public Weighs In As Supt.’s Private Eval Continues

by Maya McFadden

While the school boardremains undecided on whether it will evaluate the superintendent in writing this year, several community members offered their own feedback onSupt. Madeline Negrón’s leadership of the school district.

That public / private evaluation of the district as a whole and of Negrón’s leadership in particular took place during last Monday’s latest regular Board of Education meeting at King/Robinson School.

The board’s official evaluation of Negrón continued in private executive session, for the second meeting in a row. The board is expected to continue its evaluation of the superintendent at its next meeting. Board leadership hasn’t yet decided whether or not to put that evaluation in writing — thereby allowing it to be requested via a public-records request. In recent years, the school board has conducted oral-only evaluations of the superintendent, which are not subject to public-records laws.

Grisel Aguilar, a family advocate at Dr. Reginald Mayo Early Childhood School, said during the public comment portion of the meeting that she changed careers after working in business for 26 years. She began working for New Haven Public Schools (NHPS) “because that lady,” meaning Negrón, “she showed me we can make a change.”

Aguilar called for the school board to support renewing the superintendent’s contract after her annual evaluation.

Negrón’s original three-year contract was extended by the Board of Educationafter her first year leading NHPS in 2023. That means her currentcontract expires June 30, 2027.

Aguilar described Negrón as a strong leader who has stepped up to address several major district concerns — like chronic absenteeism — that previous leaders left unaddressed. “She is the only superintendent who has put forth a concrete, actionable plan to address long overdue building repair, ensuring our children learn,” Aguilar said.

Jennifer Hartley, a NHPS parent for 17 years, also spoke up Monday in support of Negrón’s leadership over the past three years. Hartley said for more than a decade her children attended 12 schools across district. She alsosaid she has spent more than seven years supporting over 1,000 immigrant NHPS students and families across 39 schools through her work with Integrated Refugee & Immigrant Services (IRIS).

“I’ve witnessed serious challenges in our district,” Hartley said. “I’ve personally known students who spent five years in our schools without developing foundational reading writing or math skills. I’ve observed school buildings in disrepair and scary, dangerous conditions on school grounds. But I’ve also seen significant and meaningful improvements during Dr. Negrón’s tenure. Since 2023, important school and district information has been increasingly accessible to families whose first language isn’t English.”

Hartley said that, while there are still problems that are unacceptable and require “sustained” attention by the district, she believes that Negrón has offered greater willingness to support students by increasing evaluations for English learners for special education needs and providing those students with accommodations. She also noted that as a parent she appreciates the improvements made under Negrón’s leadership with district communications — like dispersing school calendars earlier, offering more advance notice of events, and introducing impactful new and accessible programs to students.

“Having an engaged bilingual superintendent is a huge asset in a district as multicultural as ours,” Hartley told the board. “Evaluate Dr. Negrón’s leadership fairly and provide the resources necessary to address the challenges that remain.”

Other members of the public spoke up more critically of the school district during Monday’s meeting.

For example, NHPS parents Theresa Grant and Nijija Ife-Waters spoke to the board about the district’s lack ofprogress in updating its policies.

Ife-Waters pointed out that many of the policies on the district’s website — like those on assault and truancy — were adopted in1995. She said for the past 15 years she has been notifying the board and recently Negrón of the “outdated” polities that aren’t reflective of 2026 community standards and norms.

“Our students are perishing for the lack of your knowledge to run this district,” Ife-Waters told the board Monday.

Grant added that “students are being disciplined, suspended, and removed from classes while families are given different answers by different people about what the written discipline policy says and what the steps for appeal are.”

She called for the district’s policiesto be revised and posted publicly forstruggles like cyberbullying, social media influences, and cellphones in classrooms.

“How can you discipline on policies that are 31 years old?” she asked. “When discipline is inconsistent and unclear, our students miss learning, they miss trust, and they miss their schools.”

Ife-Waters and Grant each called for the district to bring parents and students to the table while updating its policies.

As of Friday, the district’s website includes policies regarding exploitation, sexual harassment, and sexual abuse prevention that have no listed adoption dates and state that the documents are “sample policies” from the Connecticut Association of Boards of Education. Another parent, Anika Russell, pointed out on Monday that the district’s suicide prevention policy has no adoption date and is a sample policy from CABE.

Click here to read the district’s current documented policies.

Another testimony offered Monday was from Kristen Hopes-McFadden, a retired NHPS history educator-turned-attorney. She made one specific demand to the board during her public remarks. She demanded the school board’s evaluation of Negrón be conducted in writing, thereby allowing the public to access it through a Freedom of Information Act request.

As a retired civics teacher, Hopes-McFadden said it sends the wrong message to conduct the evaluation orally in executive session — which would continue to preventtaxpayers, parents, students, and the community from accessing the full evaluation.

The public is entitled to know “how the Board of Education evaluates its highest paid leader and what standards are set and met,” she said.

“The only superintendents that would want their evaluation private would seem to be those with something to hide,” Hopes-McFadden concluded.

Board of Education President OrLando Yarborough did not provide the Independent with a comment by publication of this article when asked last week whether the board has decided if it will conduct its superintendent evaluation in writing or orally this year. The board did meet in executive session for two hours during its second evaluation discussion Monday.


Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Latest

National

Related news

Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading