by Lisa Reisman
Toward the end of the most recent quarterly meeting of the Hamden Newhall Neighborhood Association (HNNA), Tonya Campbell posed a question to the panel of experts convened at Hamden’s Breakthrough Church.
“What happens,” she asked, “if the cost of repairs on my home exceeds its value?”
Campbell is the vice president of the HNNA, a group formed in 2024 with a mission to fight for funds sufficient to repair the crumbling homes caused by years of New Haven manufacturers dumping industrial waste — and a remediation effort that didn’t leave the job done.
That describes Campbell’s Newhall home. There are cracks in her kitchen walls and the rear stoop is pulling away from her house. There were repairs in 2015 after the soil in her yard was found to be contaminated. That was part of the remediation effort. Despite a steel girder lodged underneath, the contractor’s shoddy workmanship made everything worse. Doors don’t close. Nor do windows. Each time it rains, water seeps into her basement.
Last year, Campbell, along with president Tina Jennings-Harriott and the rest of the HNNA team, rode their unofficial guiding principle — “it ends with us” — to a budget of approximately $18 million in federal, state, and local funding to repair the foundations. There was jubilation.
This was, it seemed, an opportunity for Campbell and her neighbors not just to “right a wrong,” as Councilwoman Rhonda Caldwell put it, but to finally make their homes habitable.
Since then, there have been four quarterly meetings, slated to keep Newhall residents apprised of developments in both the foundations repair and the demolition of the former middle school, which also sits on contaminated ground.

“Incremental progress,” was how Jennings-Harriott characterized those developments.
New HNNA office on Mather Street.
Campbell, who was hosting the meeting earlier this month, announced the composition of an oversight committee that will include community members, as well as town and state officials and legislative council members. HNNA also has a new office space, she told the 40 neighbors gathered in the church, “where community members can be heard, ideas can grow, and partnerships can begin.”
There were updates on both projects. While the bid documents for the middle-school demolition are complete, the 30-day bid process and 30-day review window means the earliest state date for the six-month project is early March.
“There’s a silver lining to the delay,” said 7 Summits Construction Company project manager Tim Barry; there were also representatives from the town, as well as the engineering consulting firm Haley & Aldrich, and BL Companies, an environmental and land surveying company. “We need water, lots of it so no dust leaves the demolition site, and we can’t use that water when it’s below freezing.”
“Silver lining,” someone in the audience said, shaking her head.

Timeline showing start of construction in April 2027.
As for the foundations repair, there are 75 homes eligible for repairs out of 150 properties assessed, with bid documents complete for the first 18 properties. “We went through those properties and we clustered them by location and type of repair,” said Barry, as a color-coded slide filled the screen. Audience members struggled to discern the image.
“Nothing can begin until the plans are put out to bid and general contractors are selected,” Hazen stressed.
Then came the Q & A.
Councilman Bob Anthony took issue with the proposed solution of dry wells, an underground water management system that captures stormwater runoff and slowly releases it into the surrounding soil through natural infiltration.
“A dry well goes down five feet,” he said, “and if the soil is poor, it won’t drain properly. That to me can be a problem.” He suggested curtain drains, which intercept and divert subsurface groundwater and surface runoff, be put around the foundations of the homes. “That way the water could go into the storm drains.”
The dry wells will be set at a sufficient distance away from basements so that water doesn’t come back into the basements, the Haley & Aldrich representative told him.
Anthony seemed unimpressed. “I’m not a property owner here,” he said, “but I know this neighborhood’s been dealing with this for over 25 years, and I worry this won’t be done right, and we wind up with homeowners having water problems again 10 years from now.”
Someone else suggested a septic system, which breaks down sewage wastewater, instead of a dry well, which is designed only to manage stormwater runoff and provides little to no biological treatment. “Are we band-aiding or are we fixing?” he asked. “Because band-aid department, 10 to 15 years later, the same thing comes up.”
Resident Chris Schurk warned that even after the middle school demolition is complete, the property would not be fully decontaminated.
“It’s not part of their project,” he said, referring to the areas beneath the tennis courts, sidewalks, and other hard surfaces. The town, he said, considered the hard surfaces a hard cap, a physical barrier to block human exposure, and made the decision against spending the extra $1.5 to $2 million to clean up while the contractors were there.
Both Hazen and assistant town engineer Jose Alvarez conceded as much, stating that if the next land use of the middle school legally required removal of the contaminated soil, they would consider it then.

HNNA vice president Tonya Campbell.
Then came from the question from Campbell, the HNNA vice president, regarding the viability of repairs to her home.
“That’s a unique situation, and that’ll be a conversation with the town and project team going over what we think your options are, and that’s all down the line,” Hazen said before declaring that the start of public bidding was “very close.”
As became evident, with “the multilayer review,” as Hazen put it, before public bidding can commence, as well as the award of contracts within 90 days of the bid opening,in addition to approvals and signoffs,that meant that, as with the middle-school demolition, no repairs will begin until, at the earliest, spring.
For Campbell and her neighbors, it’s the reality of another winter to contend with black mold, flooded basements, and uncertainty as to whether to invest in repairs or wait, and no end in sight.
“We’ve come this far,” Campbell exhorted her neighbors in her closing remarks. “Let’s keep showing up. Let’s keep questioning. Let’s keep letting our voices be heard.”

HNNA members and town officials gathered at opening of HNNA new headquarters on Mather Street.
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



