by Allan Appel
But that’s exactly How (pun?) Prof. David Blight began his “Union Victory, Confederate Defeat, and Emancipation” lecture, the 13th of 26 talks that comprise Yale’s “America at 250: A History public course.”
After heart rates of the 400 students and community members gathered in Battell Chapel lowered a bit, Blight leaned into his podium and whispered in a gravely voice, “If only it was all about the glory.”
In the next 56 minutes, the Pulitzer Prize-winning scholar of the Civil War, slavery, and of Frederick Douglas, offered a kind of tour, both aerial and grassroots, of the 1860 to 1865 years, which he termed “the greatest rupture in American history. “
The through line was searching for the meaning, or rather the multiple meanings, of that tragic time for its participants, and maybe, down through the generations for us too.
I guess, he said, with pre-emptive irony, is the obvious lesson that civil wars are really bad!
He quoted from Herman Meliville’s “The Slain Collegians” and with particular emotion from the “Wound Dresser,” the graphic, heartbreaking verses Walt Whitman composed based on his three years nursing the wounded and dying in military hospitals. Blight said, “How do you get to the meaning and understanding of the cornfield at Antietam, the carnage at Cemetery Ridge on July 3, 1863 in Gettysburg, or to the bodies, six and seven piled on top of each other in the trenches, some still alive and screaming, at Spotsylvania Courthouse” in Virginia in 1864?
His answer: “The deepest meaning of the Civil War starts with the 750,000 young men who died.”
While death was common in the culture of mid-19th century America, with the war it became a pre-occupation as it was so pervasive, and “never on this scale, and it took generations even to recover, even if we have.”
People said high minded things at the beginning of the war, Blight reported, based on newspaper reports, diaries, and letters. “The outpouring of patriotism was unbelievable,” he said after the triggering attack on Fort Sumter. “After 100 cannons fired on the flag, something had to be done,” he paraphrased the heat of the era.
Then for other Northerners, the Union was the protector of an essential identity, which went beyond and far deeper than politics to an emotional core. On many occasions Lincoln equated secession with anarchy, he said.
Southerners, on the other hand, now conceived of the Union as threat. Early on, in part to whip up a war spirit, they invoked the spirit of the country’s founding. “We’re the new spirit of ’76,” Blight paraphrased, fighting against the tyranny and the oppression of the North.
Apart from the political and economic grievances widespread against “fanatical Yankee abolitionists” and those who wanted to stop the spread of slavery in the new states and territories, Blight quoted a young Southerner writing to his sister that war was worth it “in defense of home and of our liberties” and the invasion by the “infidel hordes.”
“Everyone says ‘liberty, liberty,’” Blight summed up the debate, by giving Lincoln the last word, from a speech the president made at what was called a sanitary fair in Baltimore, in 1864.
A sanitary fair was the term for an event that raised resources for the Union soldiers and Lincoln’s attending this was one of the rare times he left the capitol and at a dark time in the Civil War:
“We all declare for liberty but in using the same word we don’t mean the same thing. To the Northern man freedom means each man can enjoy the product of his labor. To the Southern man it conveys mastership, to do as they please with another.”
No one, Blight said, ever had to ask Abraham Lincoln, what do you mean!
Though an admirer of Lincoln, Blight is no mythologizer and just as the war, he said, quoting Ralph Waldo Emerson, must always be “realist,” and never treated with sensationalism or romance, so with Lincoln.
“He was a colonizer to the core, until he wasn’t,” Blight said, referring to the widespread ante-bellum plans to solve America’s race problems by sending the country’s Negroes away – usually to Africa.
And in one of the early drafts of the Emancipation Proclamation, later taken out, were lines advocating colonizing.
And a little more on Lincoln: “The greatest fact you can know about Lincoln is that he had the racism of the era – he especially liked to tell racist jokes –but he had the capacity to grow.”
Blight’s favorite description of Lincoln was from a 1922 essay by W.E.B. Du Bois: “I love him, not because he was perfect, but because he was not. . . Despising Negroes and then letting them fight and vote. He was a man, a big, inconsistent, brave man.”
If there was any romance or a hero to the Blight lecture, that fell perhaps to Frederick Douglass. Lincoln invited him, the most famous Negro in America, to the White House to ask him if should run for re-election.
The war was grievous, casualties enormous, all tunnel and yet no light. However, having made the pivotal decision to conduct an election during war time — is there a lesson from the past here for the present? — Lincoln felt, per Blight, that there was a strong possibility he would lose to Gen. George McClellan, the Democrat, who was likely pro-slavery (though pro-Union) and was running on a platform to end the Civil War with negotiation, not victory.
Lincoln was being blamed for emancipation, for the “Black freedom that was endangering the country,” forcing inter-racial marriage. Perhaps not surprisingly, the dark web of the era, as it were, was suggesting his love for the Negro was such that secretly the 16th president should be named Abraham Africanus.
Lincoln asked Douglass if he should back away from emancipation in order to get elected and Douglass of course said no. But the issue was so fraught, Douglass was not even allowed to campaign for Lincoln.
The election was held, Lincoln prevailed, and a week later Douglass gave a sermon in the church he had grown up in and fled from, in Maryland — a state that had just voted, by extremely narrow margins, to be a slave-free state.
The sermon, Blight paraphrased, described the country in that moment as a Noah’s ark, buffeted by the terrible waves of war, near to finding land, but not being certain until Noah sends out a dove, and, finally, it returns to the ark with a twig in its mouth.
“’Today I am the dove, I am the rainbow in the sky,’” Douglass preached in Blight’s re-telling, “’a former slave in the free state of Maryland.’ That’s how critical Douglass thought was the re-election of Lincoln and the prosecuting of the war until its end.
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



