by Laura Glesby

Among the crowd was Fateria Sheats, Christian Community Action’s landlord engagement specialist.

Mayor Justin Elicker: Affordable housing solutions should include supportive housing. Credit: Laura Glesby Photo
Mayor Justin Elicker hopes to foster more “supportive housing” in New Haven: apartment complexes embedded with social services for tenants who are struggling with mental health or addiction.
He returned again and again to that concept when pressed by a room of housing activists on how he plans to address the affordable housing crisis.
Over 35 tenant activists, social service providers, legal and policy advocates, and at least one landlord filled a meeting room in the Dixwell Q House meeting room on Wednesday evening for a conversation with the mayor. The event was hosted by the Room For All Coalition.
The conversation was powered entirely by audience questions. Attendees had the opportunity to write down their questions on white index cards at the start of the meeting, and a panel of moderators read them aloud to the mayor, one by one.
Many attendees had personal experience with housing insecurity, including a large contingent from the advocacy group Mothers and Others for Justice (MOFJ). They were encouraged to speak from that experience.
MOFJ co-coordinator Myra Smith started the meeting by recounting her own past experiences with eviction and homelessness.
“We know the power of testimony. We know the power of telling your story. And we know the power of lived experience,” she told the room. “We don’t need professionals to come in to tell us… what they see, what they’ve read. We’ve lived it. Some of us are still in it.”
Personal stories trickled in to some of the questions. ”My two grown daughters had to move back in with me, along with my four grandchildren under the age of eight,” one question stated. “I am 70 years old, and I’m retired. What is being done about lowering rents?”
Elicker responded to questions about the rising cost of rent with multiple prongs.
He cited the Fair Rent Commission as a resource to which tenants can appeal if they are facing a steep rent increase. And he spoke of his support for a growing number of tenants unions across the city.
At the heart of the issue, he said, is a question of supply and demand. He argued that the more housing units are available locally, the lower rents will become.
“I think that the main way to solve this challenge is more housing,” he said.
“Since I’ve been mayor, we’ve brought over 5,000 new units or renovated units online,” Elicker said. “In the past year, we had 1,500 new units, just under 20 percent affordable. We’ve got a goal for another 5,800 units that are in the pipeline now. So we’re building a lot of housing.”

Moderator Lisa McKnight.
Some advocates were skeptical of the impact of some of the new apartment complexes on New Haven’s affordability crisis.
“What is being done to make sure that the new developments that have affordable units are really considering people from certain backgrounds, or with credit score barriers?” one question asked. “Tenants are concerned that students and Yale employees are more favored for these buildings.”
Elicker responded that as developments go up, “we really push to have as much deeply affordable as possible so that folks that are really struggling can have access to those.”
He was also asked about any planned revisions to the city’s Inclusionary Zoning ordinance. The ordinance, which passed in 2022 after being proposed by the Elicker Administration, provides incentives including tax abatements, minimum-parking waivers, and unit-size relief to new housing developments downtown and in surrounding neighborhoods that build varying percentages of “affordable” housing reserved for people making 50 percent of the Area Median Income. In 2026, according to state guidelines, that income limit would amount to $61,600 for a family of four.
Elicker said on Wednesday night that aside from a few small-scale buildings, “we’ve seen no development under the Inclusionary Zoning” ordinance. He said that most recently developed affordable housing in New Haven was made possible by a state or federal subsidy.
“The whole idea with Inclusionary Zoning is to incentivize the development of affordable housing without us putting money into doing it,” Elicker said. So he believes that the Inclusionary Zoning ordinance needs some tweaking in order to find an effective balance of incentives for developers.
“Frankly, what we’re thinking is we need to lower the requirement for the number of housing units that are affordable,” he said. “And that may seem counterintuitive to some… But if we don’t have any units built with this zoning code, then there’s not gonna be any affordable housing.”
The city is now trying to figure out the exact details of how the ordinance should be changed, Elicker said.
Beyond housing that comes organically from the development market, Elicker pointed to government-subsidized supportive housing as a critical solution to the affordable housing crisis.
“One of the challenges that we found, particularly with a significant portion of people that are experiencing chronic homelessness… is that they often have other challenges,” like substance use dependence or mental illness.
According to Elicker, there’s a need for more housing “with a caseworker attached to it” — someone checking in on tenants, asking “Hey, did you pay your rent? Did you go to your medical appointment? That sort of thing.”
“If you have supportive housing, someone’s much more likely to be successful in that housing, and not be evicted,” Elicker said.
He said later that the main challenge with the city’s non-congregate homeless shelter at 270 Foxon Blvd., run by the local nonprofit Continuum of Care, is that many shelter residents have struggled to find a more permanent place to stay.
“A lot of the folks in the [shelter] are struggling with some other challenges as well, and will not be successful if you just” hand someone some keys, Elicker said. He specifically named substance use and mental health challenges; Continuum of Care leaders have also noted that many shelter residents have complex medical needs and may need onsite medical support in their new homes.
Fateria Sheats, the landlord engagement specialist at Christian Community Action, stressed the importance of setting up landlord-tenant relationships for success from the start. She said that one bad experience with a formerly unhoused tenant can prompt the landlord to generalize and deter them from renting to another tenant in a similar situation.
“I know landlords that have tried to help, and then they got burned,” Sheats said.
Elicker said that the city has been advocating for more state funding to subsidize permanent supportive housing projects intentionally designed for tenants who may have trouble living without additional support.
At the same time, he said, “We’re looking for more units in the city, if you know any small landlords that want to kind of partner with us with these programs,” Elicker added. Landlords “that are willing to open their doors to some folks that, you know, may be somewhat challenging, but also have a real hope for a different life.”
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



