36.4 F
New Haven
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
- Advertisement -spot_img

Judiciary Committee Hears Testimony On Raising Arrest Age, Changing Handcuff Rules For Children

HARTFORD, CT – For hours, members of the legislative Judiciary Committee heard firsthand testimony about how children – some of them as young as eight years old – are affected by being handcuffed. But in the end, most of the discussion on Senate Bill 1542 centered on balancing the future of juvenile offenders against the rights of the victims of their crimes.

The bill seeks to raise the age at which a child can be arrested from 10 to 12 years old by 2026, and to 14 by 2028, except for cases involving certain serious crimes. It also would restrict the use of handcuffs on children under age 14.

The problem, according to Marc Donald, CEO of the Bridgeport-based nonprofit Catalyst CT, is that the criminal justice system acts like a spiderweb, snaring and entangling any youths that touch it.

“Children under the age of 14 are still in critical stages of emotional and cognitive development and often do not fully comprehend the consequences of their actions,” Donald told the committee.

Donald’s organization seeks to divert juveniles from the justice system through restorative practice interventions, and claims that 90% of clients avoid future arrests or rearrests.

“The bill’s provision to prevent the arrest or adjudication of children under 12 (beginning in 2026) and under 14 (beginning in 2028) … aligns with what research has shown: Punitive measures are not effective for young children and instead, they should be diverted toward rehabilitation and support.”

But state Rep. Craig Fishbein, R-Wallingford, questioned where the line was in arresting a juvenile. 

“The legislation in front of us would preclude arresting a juvenile for anything other than a Class A or B felony,” he said. He pointed out that strangulation and criminally negligent homicide are misdemeanors and that second-degree assault with a firearm is a Class C felony. In theory, then, a 12-year-old could engage in a mass school shooting and injure 20 fellow students. But if none died, the student could not be arrested.

Donald, while calling Fishbein’s example “a hypothetical that has never happened in the history of the United States,” acknowledged that the bill was not all-encompassing and that there were provisions for extreme circumstances.

State Rep. Kadeem Roberts, D-Norwalk, called out the use of hypothetical situations, asking instead for examples from Donald’s experience.

“We’re giving hypotheticals on an assault that has never happened,” he said.

Melissa Goemann, representing the National Youth Justice Network, echoed the sentiments of many speakers in saying that “young children simply lack the developmental maturity to be held criminally responsible. They are fundamentally different from older youth and adults in their cognitive, emotional, and moral development.”

She said children lack impulse control, are highly susceptible to external pressures, and do not fully understand the consequences of their actions.

“Arresting young children does not address the root causes of offending or prevent future offending,” Goemann said. “This bill would establish effective alternatives to prosecution of young children by creating pathways to youth and family-centered interventions that Connecticut already has in place.”

While most of the speakers Wednesday supported raising the age at which children can be arrested, the CT Police Chiefs Association submitted testimony opposing the change.

“Officers are very compassionate and use sound judgement when applying discretion when detaining an individual or making a decision to make an arrest or send a juvenile through a diversionary program,” the association wrote. “Unfortunately, when those bad behaviors are not corrected it may lead to juveniles continuing to commit repeat offenses and oftentimes escalating to more serious crime.”

The bill also does not account for victim impact, the associate wrote, as “victims of crimes are often left with a financial loss and this bill does not address restitution when a juvenile commits a crime.”

The association also took exception to limiting the use of handcuffs on juvenile offenders.

“Officers’ decisions to handcuff a juvenile or individuals are determined by the offender’s actions, number of individuals involved, type of call and/or information discovered that is a concern for public safety,” the chiefs wrote. “Additionally, handcuffs are used as a way to protect the officer, victims of crimes and the individual being arrested.”

However, Edgardo Patron testified that being placed in handcuffs as a young child exacerbated his situation. He said he had been expelled from kindergarten at age 5 for acting out due to trauma from child abuse. He was 12 the first time he was handcuffed, he said.

“The trauma of those cuffs on my wrists had caused me to be desensitized to arrest,” he said. “It wasn’t so bad the second time.” 

Barbara Fair, director of the group Stop Solitary CT, agreed with Patron.

“Handcuffing children is deeply traumatic,” she said in her written testimony. “Trauma doesn’t just go away once the cuffs are removed and we must come to grips with the fact that not every (14-year-old) will receive this treatment. The children most likely to be treated in this manner live in New Haven, Bridgeport, Hartford and Waterbury where resources are scarce and poverty is high.”

DeVaughn Ward said he sees the long-term impact of policies that criminalize children on a daily basis. Ward, representing the Office of Correction Ombudsman, said the use of restraints on children “sends a damaging message about who a child is and what they are capable of becoming.”

“The earlier a child is introduced into the justice system, the more likely they are to experience long-term negative outcomes including future incarceration, disrupted education, and lifelong health disparities,” Ward testified. “SB 1542 acknowledges what we know to be true: that children, especially those in their formative years, deserve supportive interventions – not punitive systems.”


Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Latest

National

Related news

Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading