36.4 F
New Haven
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
- Advertisement -spot_img

In School Board Race, Dem Vies For One More Term; Republican Targets “Wasteful” Spending

by Maya McFadden

After a decade on the New Haven Board of Education, school board secretary and Democratic candidate Edward Joyner is running for one last term — as he points with pride to recent superintendent appointments, and promises closer oversight of private school-district-hired contractors.

Bridgeport teacher, New Haven native, and local Republican Party chair John Carlson is challenging Joyner for the role — with a vow to cut “wasteful” spending and make the school district’s budget and operations more transparent.

Both candidates are running in the Nov. 4 general election for one of two elected seats on the Board of Education. Early voting has already begun.

While elected school board members usually serve four-year terms, the seat that Joyner and Carlson are vying for this time around has a two-year term. That means this same seat will be up for election for a new four-year term in 2027, when all other municipal elected offices — including mayor and alder — transition from two-year to four-year terms as well.

There are currently seven voting members on the Board of Education, as well as two non-voting student members. The two elected voting members — Joyner and Andrea Downer, both Democrats — each represent one half of the city. (Downer is not up for reelection this year.) The five other voting members include the mayor and four mayoral appointees.

In recent interviews with the Independent, Joyner, 78, and Carlson, 56, both emphasized the importance of reassessing New Haven Public Schools’ (NHPS) finances to allocate more funding to student learning and to classrooms. They differ, however, on how to make such a plan a reality.

Joyner told the Independent that his lifelong dream of being a public education advocate began in segregated schools in Farmville, North Carolina. He started his New Haven career in 1970 as a longterm substitute at the former Lee High School, now Hill Regional Career High School. He spent a significant portion of his career moving up the ranks at Hillhouse High School as a teacher, coach, administrative assistant, then assistant principal. During his time at Hillhouse, Joyner introduced the school’s first African American History curriculum.

Later Joyner held roles ranging from assistant professor at the Yale Child Study Center to executive director of Yale’s School Development Program and director of Sacred Heart University’s five-year master’s program in education.

Carlson, meanwhile, has taught in the Bridgeport public school district for 26 years. He has previously run for mayor, state senate, and alder. He told the Independent he entered this year’s race for the Board of Education to address what he sees as the district’s “wasteful spending” and lack of accountability.

Carlson grew up with both parents working in New Haven’s school system. His father was a custodian at Prince Street School and his mother worked part time as a cafeteria staffer at Kimberly School.

“I know where money should and shouldn’t be spent,” Carlson told the Independent. “New Haven wastes a lot of money.”

Joyner argued that his relationships with current school board members and district leaders, as well as his past experience in developing cost-benefit analyses for other local and state organizations, position him well to continue helping the city’s school district make progress.

Carlson said his teaching experience and knowledge about students’ needs would help him hold the system accountable.

Joyner: “All Private Services, They Have To Be Assessed”

Joyner, who has served on the Board of Education for ten years, said he’s seeking a final term to continue making the school board function more effectively by being presented with complete information before votes are taken.

When asked what he is most proud of doing during his decade on the school board, he described the district’s hiring of Iline Tracey and then Madeline Negrón to be superintendent. He also described the district’s current department and subject-area leads as “highly skilled” and setting the district in the right direction.

“Dr. Tracey doesn’t get enough credit for keeping us afloat during such a hard time,” Joyner said about the previous superintendent’s leadership during the Covid-19 pandemic. “And I believe Dr. Negrón can lead us through this next period.”

Joyner credited the current school board for focusing more on service than politics and said the relationship between the board and the mayor is “the best I’ve ever seen,” which he’s also proud of. Still, he added, “we have miles to go before we sleep.”

Joyner said that he feels the district has a superintendent and mayor that are fighting for education funding for all that the state “doesn’t fully invest in.” He added that he feels the current board members are “dedicated to service not patronage,” making it so the board is functioning better than it has in the past.

If elected to one more term, Joyner said his focus would remain on pushing district leaders to see if investments are generating the results needed or if programs and resources can instead be consolidated. This will keep the district accountable for its focus on its students, he said. He also said he’ll focus on pushing for increased state funding.

“Right now, New Haven is getting half of the pizza. Our citizens are paying the cost for privileges that other communities rely on,” he said. “They’re cheating children in cities like New Haven and the governor could do something about it.”

Joyner said reallocation of resources — not blanket administrative cuts — is key to improving outcomes. “We need to see if our investments are generating results,” he said. “Nothing is out of bounds. All private services, they have to be assessed.”

While the district still has to work to adequately staff “every sector of the school system” and provide staff and students with the needed building resources, he said, much of it comes down to state funding even after the district evaluates and reassesses its current spending.

He said that evaluating the system completely would also require leaders to reassess NHPS’ reliance on private contracts for legal and facilities work. Over the past year, Joyner has asked district leadership repeatedly to implement early warning systems for costly contract change orders and facilities evaluations and oversight to be sure “we’re spending on quality work.”

“Since we have limited revenue we have got to think about reallocation of resources and by that I mean we need more resources diverted to the classrooms and buildings. It’s a lot of work but it’s critical for us to do right now,” he said.

Joyner also plans to push in his final term for the district to invest in trainings for its building leaders to understand labor law and analyze staffing contracts to avoid costly litigation. 

“We wouldn’t have so many disputes if people understood the law, we’ve got to do something there,” he said.

Joyner concluded, “With my experience and sense of urgency, I can be a voice of instruction and reason.”

Carlson: District Needs Help Overcoming “Wasteful” Spending, Poor Reading Rates

In a separate interview, Carlson also said that his top goal is to ensure the district’s resources are spent directly on students. He, however, believes cuts to “wasteful” administration spending is a necessary first step that he’ll push for if elected.

“I just want to make it clear I’m not going into this to oppose anyone,” he said. “But if something’s not good for the students, I’ll let everyone know — the public and the press and the board will know — so there’s a light on it.”

Carlson also criticized what he described as years of poor student-reading proficiency. He said the board is in need of change because Mayor Justin Elicker and his four voting-school-board-member appointees have in recent years “produced the worst reading scores in the state.”

The Independent was not able confirm that New Haven currently has the lowest reading proficiency in the state. New Haven did have 22 percent of students reading at grade level in 2023. Meanwhile, in 2023, Bridgeport reported data that 23 percent of students were reading at grade level. On July 14, NHPS Supt. Madeline Negrón noted in an end-of-year report in July that Smarter Balance Assessment (SBA) reading scores increased by .5 percent to 23.9 percent. (This report did not indicate whether this number is for several grade levels or just one.)

“A landlord would be fined if a rental was in such condition, yet the mayor and BOE accept it for New Haven students. It’s unacceptable,” Carlson said.

Carlson also said he supports considering school consolidations to save money for classrooms if it’s needed. He suggested cutting redundant central office positions and assistant principals from smaller school buildings. Joyner agreed that if further building consolidation is needed, he will push for there to be a standard set for school closures that gives staff and students advanced notice.

Both candidates said they would take into consideration a school’s enrollment numbers and the age of the building to consider future closures or mergers.

“Any money being saved should be put directly toward at-risk kids with below-grade-level reading scores,” Carlson said. “We don’t need more funding. We need to budget what we have correctly.”

Both Carlson and Joyner called for a fully transparent line-by-line NHPS budget to be released publicly.

Carlson said if the district must hire out for maintenance work, he would push for contractors to be New Haven businesses. Carlson said those businesses would “not only contribute to the community financially, but local people and their local employees would probably take more pride in their jobs, as they would possibly have their own relatives in the schools, as well as friends and neighbors’ children.”

If elected to the board, Carlson said he will not “fear for my relatives’ job security if they don’t go along with the mayor” and added if Republican mayoral candidate Steve Orosco is elected mayor, he looks forward to his plans to push for a fully elected school board. “We should try to do what others do because we’re not in a place to be emulated.  And those other districts at the top have fully elected Boards of Education.” 

“As a board member elected by the people, I will shine a light on everything they do,” Carlson concluded. “When I go before the public and board, I will share a plan and explain why it works and why it’s a good plan, just like teaching a class.”

Update: Reached for comment Thursday afternoon for a response to Carlson’s remarks about “relatives’ job security,” Joyner said he doesn’t appreciate Carlson’s “attack” on him, his family, and the mayor.

Joyner’s daughter, Monica Joyner, has worked as NHPS’ supervisor of mathematics since 2022. She previously was an assistant principal at Career High School.

“This is simply a low ball attack on my family and is not what I would expect from someone whom I have respected in the past,” Joyner said. “I am running on my merits and every family member of mine was more than qualified for the job.”

He added that Elicker has demonstrated a high standard of ethical leadership and “would never ask anyone to do anything transactional like what Carlson is implying. I cannot say the same thing about the leader of his party.”


Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Latest

National

Related news

Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading