39.7 F
New Haven
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
- Advertisement -spot_img

Founding Words Fire Annual Read Into American History

by Allan Appel The New Haven independent

One way to grapple with urgent political matters is to read or re-read the Declaration of Independence and other significant historical documents from the past, of the evolving story of America as it labors to perfect its imperfect union.

That’s why Sarah Greenblatt, the president of the Historic Wooster Square Association, and Justin Farmer, a former Hamden legislator, joined 150 others Monday afternoon on the second floor of the Beinecke Rare Book Library at Yale.

They were on hand for the eighth annual reading of the Declaration of Independence, Frederick Douglass’s ​“What, To The American Slave, Is Your 4th of July?,” and other documents, as organized by City Historian and Beinecke Director of Engagement Michael Morand. 

The goal of Monday’s annual reading, as Morand put it, is so that New Haveners might ​“avoid being part of what Gore Vidal called the ​‘United States of Amnesia.’”

In a tone of somber authority Yale historian David Blight read the Declaration, a bill of complaints and ​“repeated chain of abuses” justifying divorce from Great Britain and her king.

When he arrived at the enumeration of ​“obstructing the administration of justice,” ​“depriving us, in many cases, of trial by jury,” ​“cutting off trade with all parts of the world,” ​“introducing absolute rule,” and ​“exciting domestic insurrection among us,” there was an audible note of rising recognition, along with indignation, in both Blight’s voice and also the held silence of the audience.

As Greenblatt said, in America today it’s a time of ​“wariness, fear, and anxiety about due process and our independence.”

And Farmer upped the ante in his jeremiad description of the present moment: ​“A time when we’re in the midst of empire and fascism, and if we’re ever going forward we all need to grapple with it.”

Blight was followed by educator Charles Warner, Jr., who read gripping excerpts — let the slave’s scarred skin be turned into parchment for the writing on it of a constitution! — from The Life of William Grimes, dating from 1825, the first printed narrative of a runaway slave.

He was followed by East Rock/Fair Haven Alder Caroline Tanbee Smith, who read the ​“Declaration of Sentiments,” an ironic and bracing feminist riff on the language of the Declaration (“We hold these truths to be self evident that all men and women are created equal”), which opened the first women’s rights convention in Seneca Falls, New York, in 1848.

The lion’s share of the reading event focused on abolitionist Frederick Douglass’s 1852 July 4th oration that includes such hypocrisy-shattering indictments as, ​“What, to the American slave, is your 4th of July? I answer: a day that reveals to him, more than all other days in the year, the gross injustice and cruelty to which he is the constant victim,” and ​“Your high independence only reveals the immeasurable distance between us.”

In addition to Farmer, the other readers who evoked Douglass’s eloquent cri de coeur were ConnCORP CEO Erik Clemons, journalist and WNHH Radio host Babz Rawls Ivy, and former Probate Court Judge Clifton Graves, Jr.

Before he took the microphone, Blight shared with the Independent a recollection of how President Donald Trump, on the eve of starting his first term in 2017, while touring the newly opened African American History Museum in Washington, said he’d heard Douglass was out there doing good work and finally getting recognized for it.

Some of Blight’s students, in session with their teaching assistant at the time, saw the remark on a TV that was switched on in the classroom. They, as a group, Blight recalled, simply gasped.

The next day Blight, equally stunned at such presidential ignorance, recalled that he began that day’s lecture with a silent visual: A photograph (as was the obituary style of the era) of Douglass lying in his open coffin.

Blight paused, while the photo spoke.

“Just to let you know he’s not alive,” the professor said to his students.

Both Blight and Ivy said of their personal experience of this July 4 that they felt little impulse to celebrate, light a firecracker, go to a barbecue, or engage in any hoopla.

“Not when our democracy is dissolving and our institutions aren’t functioning,” Blight said.

Instead, on Monday afternoon, they and others read — and listened to — the documentary voices from our past that speak to how democracy is not the forever given, as many of us felt it to be when we were little kids innocently reciting the pledge of allegiance in the school yard.

In fact it’s often a tale of woe and of horrible mistakes, which democracy is prone to, such as the Civil War-inciting Fugitive Slave Act, a judicial failure that led to human trafficking nightmares and tragic consequences Douglass describes with heartbreaking example.

The poignancy and power of these documents is in how they time-travel you back to when a king could obstruct the administration of local American justice, or to the family saying their final goodbyes on the slave block — to the profound struggles of previous generations as a potent reminder that there are no givens, and now it’s our turn to set things right. Or not.

Fortunately Douglass himself rose from the grave through his cascading rhythmic and graphic oratory to offer at least a fillip of optimism. For as the stemwinder, read with passion and purpose by Ivy, concluded, he said, ​“I don’t despair this country … the doom of slavery is certain.”

Allan Appel Photo At the Beinecke.

Beinecke organizer Michael Morand and attendee Ann Langdon-Days.


Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Latest

National

Related news

Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading