by Mona Mahadevan The New Haven independent

Edge of the Woods’ open rows of conventional and organic produce, seated beneath green garlands draped across the ceiling.
At the entrance of Edge of the Woods, a large, fluffy brown bear holds a sign that pleads, “Please, don’t poke the bear.” For decades, he’s stood watch as customers filled their baskets with chocolate sesame syrup, dried papaya, herbal supplements, all-natural soap, and freshly ground peanut butter.
Where chains like Whole Foods have traded neighborhood charm for chrome finishes and sleek displays, Edge of the Woods — opened almost 50 years ago and still run by its founding family — has endured as a stubbornly local institution.
The vegetarian market’s Elm City roots stretch back to 1977, when Peter Dodge, then a 20-something yogi, opened the store as a customer co-op at the intersection of Edgewood Avenue and Platt Street.
“I saw a real need for a natural foods grocery store in New Haven,” Dodge told the Independent. He had moved to the city in 1976 as a volunteer for Ananda Marga, a socio-spiritual organization that promotes meditation, yoga, and service. When he couldn’t find a local grocer that catered to his diet — a form of lacto-ovo vegetarianism — he decided to open one himself.
The store initially operated as a nonprofit owned by a legal entity affiliated with Ananda Marga. Dodge split his time between the New Haven store and a for-profit natural foods store he ran in Branford, then called Orchard Hill Market.
After a few years, feeling the itch to “be [his] own being,” Dodge stepped away from Edge of the Woods to focus full-time on Orchard Hill, leaving the New Haven store in the hands of his fellow Ananda Marga devotees.
But the co-op soon ran into financial trouble. By the early ’80s, the store’s Board of Directors opted to sell the store to Dodge.
He left the Branford business, converted Edge of the Woods into a for-profit operation, and committed full-time to New Haven, which he believed had “a stronger natural foods clientele.”
“It was radical to be vegetarian back then,” he explained, “and there were lots of young people here willing to do things differently.”
By the late 1980s, aided by the growing popularity of vegetarianism, companies like Pacific Foods and Tofurky began introducing new plant-based options to the market.
Around the same time, Dodge caught wind that Bread & Circus — a natural foods chain later acquired by Whole Foods — was eying a large location on Norton Street.
Betting on growth in the natural foods industry and his ability to outcompete the chain, Dodge purchased a larger location in a former theater and nightclub at 379 Whalley Ave., where the store remains today.
The building had fallen into disrepair — “a dripping cavern,” Dodge called it — but he admired its “nice bones,” “high ceilings,” and past lives, most notably as a theater.
Shafiq Abdussabur, a former neighborhood alder, retired police sergeant, and long-time Edge patron, remembered the former Whalley Avenue theater well. “We’d go back there on Sundays,” he said, and “get the matinee for two movies, back-to-back.”
It took a year to transform the crumbling cavern into a two-story grocery store. Dodge pointed out the items he crafted by hand, like the orange‑y wooden shelves on the second-floor mezzanine.

According to Justin Dodge, the floors may soon be getting an upgrade, thanks in part to a revitalization grant from the city.
Looking back, Dodge described those early years as precarious at best.
In one especially stressful moment, he sat alone in his office, repeating a soothing mantra: “If I’m successful, great. If I’m not successful, great.”
It wasn’t resignation, he explained, so much as perspective. “The goal in life shouldn’t be to just make money and have a family,” he said. “It’s about becoming enlightened,” a state he described as when “all the ego and mental processes expand to a blissful state.”
Dodge credits that sense of serenity, along with “lots of prayer” and a loyal base of customers, with keeping the store afloat.

The bulk foods section, sourced from 4-5 different suppliers.
Today, the market offers a mix of conventional pantry staples and hard-to-find organic items. The shelves are packed with options that fit a wide range of diets, including halal, kosher, vegan, and gluten-free.
Abdussabur, a devout Muslim, said the store reflects the city’s diversity, drawing customers of many different races, religions, and cultures. “When you walk into Edge of the Woods, it looks just like New Haven,” he said.
Past the standard grocery aisles, a bakery, hot food counter, and bulk section stock fresh bread, prepared meals, and rows of grains, spices, and dried fruit. There’s also a second floor filled with holistic health and wellness products.
The interior has expanded over the last few decades, but it still feels familiar and full of heart, replete with hand-painted signs, amber overhead lighting, and green garlands draped across the ceiling.
Since the move to Whalley, what fills its shelves has evolved alongside the natural foods industry, even as the space has mostly stayed the same.
“We used to buy soy milk by the pallet,” said Dodge. “Now, soy hardly exists,” crowded out by carton after carton of other plant-based alternatives. On Thursday afternoon, the shelves were packed with maple walnut, vanilla hemp, coconut almond, flax protein, and sweetened hazelnut “milks.”
Dodge pointed to the proliferation of milks as indicative of how the natural foods industry — and the store’s customer base — has grown over time.
He and his team do their best to keep up by assessing and rotating products weekly, but he admitted that it can be hard to separate the wheat from the chaff given the speed of innovation in the plant-based sector.

Peter Dodge today, behind the customer service counter.
Dodge said his wife, Frances, has worked alongside him since the beginning, eventually taking over the store’s finances. Their grandson, Alvin, also contributes to the operation.
“When you own a business, everyone’s involved,” Dodge explained.
His sons, Nathan and Justin, cherish their memories of growing up at the store. With a smile, Justin said, “I rode my Razor scooter through the aisles.”
After graduating high school, the two brothers left Edge of the Woods to explore other paths for a few years before returning to work at the store full-time.
Now, they’re primed to take over, as soon as Peter hands over his apron.
So what comes next for Edge of the Woods?
“New Haven is growing,” said Nathan. “Professional people are coming in, downtown is growing exponentially — we want to kind of grow with it.” He imagines reaching more of the city, broadening the customer base without losing what makes the store feel so familiar.
He’s also exploring the idea of outdoor seating (“tree-top dining,” keeping with the store’s woodsy theme).
Justin, for his part, plans to redo the store’s roof and floors, potentially with financial support from the city. He’s also interested in installing an espresso machine, ice cream counter, and salad bar.
But for all their plans, the brothers remain committed to the old-school ethos that makes Edge of the Woods such a beloved institution.
“If we keep moving the way we’re going, the choice will be between Amazon and Walmart,” Justin said. For him and Nathan, that concern has only deepened their devotion to the store’s raison d’etre: of staying “a mom-and-pop-shop, serving healthy food to a growing community.”

Nathan Dodge stocks shelves in a building adjacent to the main store.

An explosion of plant-based milks!
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



