
Rev. Perkins, with Rev. Empsall and Rabbi Schaefer: “This 10-point list does not seem to match the urgency of the moment.”

Sister Burns: “Do we really want to stand on principle and let the Republicans pass a bill with no changes?”

Rev. Mathis: Focus on building electoral support rather than “rant[ing] in a safe, padded room.”
U.S. Rep. Rosa DeLauro emphasized her support on Friday for imposing “serious constraints” on Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) — and pushed back on calls from some local faith leaders to get rid of the agency altogether.
The discussion joins a national debate over the slogan “Abolish ICE,” a demand that reflects growing public outage from reports of masked federal agents detaining American citizens, clashing with nonviolent protestors, and sowing fear and chaos among migrant communities.
In Hamden’s Congregation Mishkan Israel, located at 785 Ridge Rd., faith leaders spent two hours pushing DeLauro and each other on whether to use the phrase “Abolish ICE.”
DeLauro opened the discussion by criticizing the “masked and armed marauding agents” that detained Wilbur Cross High School student Esdrás Zabaleta-Ramirez, raided a car wash in Hamden, and, in Minnesota, put a five-year-old boy in detention and shot and killed two U.S. citizens, Alex Pretti and Renee Good.
“I will be fighting for serious constraints” in the funding bill for the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), said DeLauro. The proposals, which were published by U.S. Sen. Chuck Schumer and U.S. Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, include mandating judicial warrants for arrests, requiring body cameras, increasing training standards, protecting places like schools and polling places, and banning face coverings.
“And if we do not get those reforms,” declared DeLauro, “I can assure you, that myself and my Democratic colleagues will vote no” to funding DHS.
Funding for DHS expires on Feb. 13. That’s because the bill ending the partial government shutdown only funded the agency for ten days, leaving a short period for DeLauro and other Democrats to build support for reforms to ICE. DeLauro — the top Democrat on the House Appropriations Committee — was one of only 21 House Democrats to support the bill, which keeps a half-dozen agencies afloat through the end of September.
“It is very disappointing to hear you say that there is some version of ICE that can be saved after everything we’ve seen happen,” said Jack Perkins, a reverend at Spring Glen Church, on Friday. “This 10-point list does not seem to match the urgency of the moment.”
Echoing those comments, Congregation Mishkan Israel’s Rabbi Daniel Schaefer argued that “reform is not enough” because the agency has “proven itself to be rotten to the core.” He called on Democratic leaders to “take much stronger stances.”
DHS “facilitate[s] legitimate trade and travel,” “stop[s] trafficking of illegal arms, drugs, [and] counterfeit goods,” “investigate[s] human and child trafficking,” and houses the U.S. Coast Guard and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), responded DeLauro. Later, she clarified, “We need enforcement at the border.”
She reminded the table that advocates have the “luxury” of taking more extreme stances, while elected officials must come to compromises in order to govern.
After some heated back-and-forth, Perkins said, “This has gotten so bad, that I would rather you vote for what is morally correct and lose, than to compromise morality.”
“Don’t talk to me about my own morality,” retorted DeLauro.
“Don’t tell your constituents what they can and can’t talk to you about,” interjected Nathan Empsall, a reverend at Episcopal Church of St. Paul and St. James.
“You can talk to me about anything you want, but you can’t talk to me about what my morality is,” said DeLauro. “I don’t challenge your morality.”
“No, your morality is wonderful,” clarified Empsall, “but what you are voting for does not match your morality.” Given that ICE is a “lawless agency” that intentionally inflicts “cruelty,” he said, agents won’t obey new reforms.
“Do we really want to stand on principle and let the Republicans pass a bill with no changes?” asked Sister Mary Ellen Burns of Fair Haven’s Apostle Immigrant Services. “Because they won’t vote for a bill to abolish ICE.” She acknowledged that reform can feel like “bargaining with the devil” but emphasized the need to consider political reality.
DeLauro agreed, adding, “Do you say, ‘throw it out,’ because you can’t get 100 percent of what you want, and that’s it? That’s not what a governing body does.”
Cantor Sierra Fox of Congregation Mishkan Israel pointed out that, just as elected officials are in the business of governing, faith leaders “have an obligation to the calling out of changes we want to see.” To that end, she asked, “How would these reforms hold people accountable when the existing laws are not doing the job?”
DeLauro pointed out that Connecticut’s attorney general and advocacy groups are suing in court and “winning the cases.” In Congress, debates over bills to regulate ICE are increasing oversight of the agency. “But the most important tool we have today is public outcry,” she said, which has been “galvanized” nationally by ICE’s overreach.
“Does [the proposal] meet all of the rage? No, it doesn’t, but it helps move the ball forward,” said DeLauro.
Bill Mathis, a reverend at Springs of Life-Giving Water Church, said his perspective reflects his identities as a Black person and lawyer. “The bottom line, which nobody’s really talking about here, is a whole lot of people” in the communities being targeted by ICE “are the people who voted for Trump,” said Mathis. He urged faith leaders to build support for change by convincing the people near them, rather than allow “our position” to be dictated “from a place of comfort” that “keeps us divided.”
Rev. Jerry Streets of the Yale Divinity School added, “I understand the diplomatic tone that has to be maintained” within governing bodies, “but I would like to see more outrage from elected leaders.”
“What are you not hearing?” asked DeLauro. She explained that the proposed reforms are “not minor in this context” and argued that most change takes years, citing the expanded child tax credit, which she has pushed since 2003.
“People are feeling helpless to make change when the infrastructure is so deeply broken,” said Fox. “We are not able to reach a point at which people feel that they are being heard, that their outrage is being recognized, and the future has a possibility of safety for those that are in the most distress.”
Burns proposed an answer from her Catholic faith: concrete action, as a way to battle despair.
“There really are the opportunities to welcome the stranger and feed the hungry and clothe the needy and give housing to the homeless,” she said. “And to the extent that you’re doing that, the battle is not lost, and really, we, as individuals, are not without hope.”
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



