by Mona Mahadevan The New Haven independent

MONA MAHADEVAN photo… versus the property today.
The city has dreams of opening a waterfront park at the highly contaminated site of the former English Station power plant, but legal challenges, environmental hazards, and financial roadblocks stand in its way.
Mayor Justin Elicker announced the city’s intention to acquire the 8.6‑acre property, located on Ball Island at 510 Grand Ave., during a press conference outside the site Monday morning.
“We’re here to say enough is enough,” Elicker said. “We want this land back for our community.”
According to a press release from the mayor’s office, the proposed Mill River Park would include “public outdoor pools, playgrounds, sports courts, walking and biking trails, and native plant gardens along the 3,000-foot waterfront property.”
At Monday’s conference, Elicker said the project could act as a “force multiplier,” spurring economic growth and new housing throughout the Mill River district. He said he hopes to see the park open within five years.
The city sent letters of interest on Monday to both of the current property owners: Paramount View Millennium, LLC and Haven Properties, LLC. Elicker told the Independent later in the day that he has not been in direct contact with the owners, though he did speak to their development partner four years ago.
Elicker also said he would prefer to reach an agreement through “good faith negotiations” but would be willing to pursue eminent domain if needed.
Even if the city can acquire the land, however, English Station needs a thorough clean-up before it is ready for public use.
High levels of carcinogens, polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), heavy metals, and other contaminants were left behind by United Illuminating (UI), which operated the property as a coal and oil-fired power plant from 1929 to 1992.
The land was sold to Quinnipiac Energy in 2000and has since changed hands multiple times, landing with a series of penny-stock swindlers, counterfeiters, and other con artists.
In 2016, UI entered into a Partial Consent Order with the state Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP), clearing the way for the company’s $3 billion acquisition by Spanish energy giant Iberdrola SA. A condition of the agreement required UI to spend at least $30 million over three years on environmental remediation.
Today, the site remains heavily contaminated and is closed to the public.
“In no way has UI proceeded expeditiously,” New Haven State Sen. and President Pro Tempore Martin Looney said on Monday. “There has been an absence of good faith, an absence of willingness to be a good partner.”
A UI spokesperson said the company has spent $22 million since 2016 on remediation, including the removal of 8,700 tons of contaminated soil and 1,300 cubic yards of asbestos, as well as 24/7 site security. Of that total, $17 million counts toward its $30 million obligation.
She claimed cleanup remained incomplete because DEEP is now requiring UI to meet a residential use standard — which is stricter than what was outlined in the 2016 consent order, and would cost the company more than $60 million. The company’s January 2024 statement about English Station, which explains its decision not to proceed with additional cleanup, can be found here.
When asked about UI’s assertions, DEEP referred the Independent to the Attorney General’s Office, which responded to other questions but did not address those specific claims.
Meanwhile, state regulators have taken steps to compel UI to follow through on the 2016 order.
In 2023, Connecticut’s Public Utilities Regulatory Agency (PURA) imposed a fine of $2 million per year for UI’s failure to complete remediation. UI sued, but a New Britain Superior Court upheld the penalty in March.
According to Katie Dykes, commissioner of Connecticut’s Department of Energy & Environmental Protection (DEEP), a second lawsuit from UI is ongoing. Once an agreement is reached over the scope of remediation required of UI, PURA will be able to impose more financial penalties if the company continues to stall clean-up efforts.
The Attorney General could also step in, according to Deputy Director of Communications Richard Funaro.
In a statement emailed to the Independent, he said, “Our office has the ability to take further enforcement action (such as contempt) in these cases after appeals processes run their course, in the event UI loses but still fails to fulfill its responsibilities to remediate the site. The Office of the Attorney General will continue to pursue all appropriate action to hold UI accountable.”
Even if UI ultimately complies, the city will need to find the money to turn English Station into a usable park.
Elicker floated a preliminary $25 million estimate for the project — a figure that includes additional remediation (beyond what UI is required to do), acquiring the property, building an outdoor pool, and installing play equipment. City spokesperson Lenny Speiller said the funding would come from a mix of city, state, federal, and philanthropic sources. Whether those funds will materialize, and whether $25 million will be enough, remains to be seen.
At the same time, the city is still figuring out what forms of recreation the site can support.
“We have a lot of confidence that the building [on the property] can be used” rather than demolished, said New Haven Urban Design League President Anstress Farwell. She added that land use firms — including Grimshaw International and Sherwood Design Engineers — will continue evaluating the site to determine its potential future uses.
Fair Haven Alder Sarah Miller was not sure if people would ever be able to swim in Mill River, but she said it was at least “a nice dream.”

New Haven Youth and Recreation Director Gwendolyn Williams spoke about racial inequity in water safety: “I didn’t learn how to swim” growing up, she said. “It’s time to break that chain.”

LEAP swim instructor Ale Cruz and lifeguard Samara Reid shared how important access to a pool has been to their lives.

Dozens of people from DEEP, PURA, Save the Sound, and the city gathered for Elicker’s announcement.
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



