By THOMAS BREEN | New Haven Independent
Four of the five city cops sued for allegedly violating Richard “Randy” Cox’s constitutional rights claim in new court filings that their actions were reasonable and covered by “qualified immunity,” arguing that the paralyzing injuries suffered by the 36-year-old New Havener while in police custody stemmed in large part from his own “negligence and carelessness.”
The Elicker Administration has taken a similar tack, invoking in a separate new court filing “governmental immunity” in the case and pointing to the now-paralyzed New Havener’s “contributory negligence.”
New Haven Police Sgt. Betsy Segui and Officers Oscar Diaz, Ronald Pressley, and Luis Rivera put forward the former set of legal defenses on Monday and Tuesday in separate federal court filings in an ongoing civil lawsuit filed by Cox.
The court filings represent the first time since Cox’s arrest on June 19 that these four police officers — in this case, through each of their lawyers — have said anything publicly about what happened that night and about their roles and responsibilities in the paralyzing injuries that Cox suffered while in police custody.
The filings come nearly two months after Cox’s legal team filed a civil lawsuit in federal court against the city and against all those same offers seeking $100 million in damages for the cops’ alleged violations of the paralyzed 36-year-old New Havener’s constitutional rights.
The officers’ invoking of “qualified immunity” refers broadly speaking to a frequently invoked portion of common law that allows officers to claim that they acted in an objectively reasonable manner in the moment of an alleged civil rights violation.
As for Cox’s purported role in his own suffering, Segui’s lawyer wrote the following in a Monday court filing in defense of his client: “The Plaintiff’s own negligence and carelessness contributed to and was a substantial factor in causing the injuries and losses alleged in the Complaint, in that: a) He failed to act as a reasonable, prudent person under the circumstances; b) He failed to comply with the lawful commands of officers on scene; and c) He actively interfered with the investigation conducted by officers on scene.”
The cops’ claims of qualified immunity in this federal court case come roughly two years after a landmark state police accountability bill championed by New Haven State Sen. Gary Winfield modified and limited state allowance for such a defense.
The only officer sued in this case to put forward a substantively different legal defense so far is Jocelyn Lavandier. Her Hartford-based attorney argued in a motion filed last week that the case should be dismissed on the grounds that his client had never been properly served.
The city cops sued in this case aren’t the only ones to have recently filed legal defenses calling for a trial by jury, claiming immunity from liability, and pointing the finger at Cox for contributing to his own injuries while in police custody.
The Elicker Administration, through a Hartford-hired defense attorney, has put forward a similar if pared down legal defense in arguing in a Monday filing that the City of New Haven is protected from this lawsuit by “governmental immunity” and by Cox’s own “contributory negligence.”
Update: In a comment provided to the Independent Wednesday for this article, city Corporation Counsel Patricia King said: “The City’s attorney filed a responsive pleading as required to preserve all the City’s rights during the legal process. The City of New Haven remains committed to pursuing an early, reasonable resolution of all issues raised in the lawsuit.”
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



