by Laura Glesby
The state’s attorney’s office intends to appeal Maleek Jones’s exoneration all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Senior Assistant State’s Attorney Jo Anne Sulik communicated that intention to U.S. District Court Judge Janet Hall at a video status conference call on Wednesday afternoon.
The conference call took place a week after the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decided to uphold Hall’s 2023 decision exonerating Jones of the murder of Eddie Harp in New Haven.
Jones had spent over 30 years incarcerated for the 1992 murder, which he always maintained he never committed. Hall overturned his conviction on the basis that the public defender at his criminal trial failed to adequately defend him, including by failing to contact the sole independent witness to the crime, whose testimony backed up the narrative that Jones was innocent. Hall also found that the trial court improperly excluded the testimony of someone to whom another shooter confessed.
On Nov. 10, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld Hall’s decision with two out of three judges in the majority. A third judge, Richard Sullivan, dissented, arguing that the district court should have shown more deference to lower courts.
In response to this decision, “We are looking to file a motion to stay the mandate while we petition for cert,” Sulik said to Hall on behalf of the state on Wednesday.
In other words, the state is planning to request that the appeals court halt the impacts of its ruling so that the state can file a petition to be heard by the U.S. Supreme Court.
The state’s attorney’s office did not respond to a request for comment in time for the publication of this article.
Over a decade ago, the 2nd Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals decided in 2015 to uphold an exoneration of another New Haven man, Scott Lewis. The state decided not to appeal that decision further, and Lewis was able to walk free with a cleared name.
Jones, on the other hand, continues to face uncertainty over whether his freedom will last.
“I mean, when does it stop?” wrote Jones in a text message on Wednesday. “After 31 years of psychological trauma and fighting for justice in the face of an injustice, I was finally released, only to spend the next three years looking over my shoulder, dealing with the anxiety of the State appealing Judge Hall’s decision. The Second Circuit upheld that decision, and just when I finally thought I could breathe and begin moving forward, the State is now taking this to the Supreme Court.”
“This is beyond exhausting,” Jones wrote. “It is offensive to me, my family, the principles of justice, and even the victim, that despite the facts and the rulings of two courts, the State remains determined to defend a conviction that should never have stood.
“At some point,” he continued, “there has to be accountability, humility, and a willingness to acknowledge when an injustice has been done. Instead, it feels like the fight for justice never ends.”
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



