by Adam Walker The New Haven independent
The City Plan Commission voted to approve plans for a new 150-room Marriott Residence Inn on Park Street — following hours of debate over parking, community input, and a restaurant to be included on the hotel’s ground floor.
Commissioners took that 3 – 1 vote of support Wednesday night during their latest monthly online-only meeting. Westville Alder and Commissioner Adam Marchand cast the sole dissenting vote.
The commission’s site plan approval came after more than three hours of public comment, legal arguments, and technical discussion. It allows Pennsylvania-based developer Penn Real Estate Group to move forward with constructing a six-story extended-stay hotel at 130 – 134 Park Street and adjacent parcels—so long as a proposed ground-floor restaurant is operated separately from the hotel and divided from it by a locked door.
The vote followed a June 18 meeting in which the commission, responding to community pressure, voted 3 – 2 to delay a decision and instead hold a public hearing. At the time, Dwight Alder Frank Douglass and nearly 120 residents — via a New Haven Rising petition titled “Hotels or Housing?” — raised concerns about limited public outreach, parking strain, and displacement pressures in a gentrifying neighborhood.
The lots in question currently contain a vacant medical office, a former laundromat, and surface parking. The Penn Real Estate Group purchased those properties for $4.7 million back in late 2019 and early 2020.
Under the approved plan, those would be replaced with a 150-room hotel featuring 31 on-site parking spaces, a private courtyard, meeting rooms, and a cafe and bar open to the public.
At Wednesday night’s hearing, City Plan Department staffer Alexander Castro reiterated the department’s recommendation for approval, stating that the project complies with BD‑1 (Central Business/Residential) zoning regulations and aligns with the city’s Vision 2025 Comprehensive Plan.
Attorney Carolyn Kone, representing the developer, described the underused block as “very sort of dark and scary,” and said the hotel would help revitalize the area while serving visitors who need long-term stays — such as medical personnel, performers, and families.
“It’s intended to be a family-oriented, mid-price hotel,” she said, highlighting free breakfast, extended-stay amenities, and job creation.
Kone presented alongside Donna Galvin, principal of the Penn Real Estate Group; Steven Gibson, the firm’s in-house architect; and Oliver Gaffney, the project’s landscape architect. Together, the team walked the commission through renderings, zoning interpretations, and site logistics.
A major point of contention was whether the cafe would qualify as a “restaurant” eligible for a liquor license or as an “eating and drinking establishment,” which would trigger additional zoning requirements.
Opponents during public testimony argued that the hotel and restaurant could not be truly separate given their physical proximity.
Eva Weintraub, a Nash Street resident who testified on behalf of the local labor advocacy group New Haven Rising, challenged the developer’s claim that the restaurant should be exempt from parking requirements.
“Number one, the applicant incorrectly claims exemption from parking requirements,” she said. “The application states that the proposed hotel and restaurant are both exempt from parking requirements in the zoning code. While the rooms of the hotel are exempt, in order for the restaurant operation to be exempt, it must fit the zoning code’s definition of a restaurant, which require it operate under a restaurant liquor permit, as provided in Section 3022 of the Connecticut General Statutes.”
Kone responded that the restaurant could qualify for such a permit if it met two key conditions: it must be physically separated from the hotel by a lockable door, and it must be operated independently. She recommended that both requirements be formalized as part of the site plan approval.
Commissioner Adam Marchand pressed for specifics, questioning how circulation between the cafe and the lobby would work and asking the development team to clarify the cafe’s layout and management. “I’m just trying to understand how the cafe space would connect with the lobby if somebody wanted to get from one to the other,” he said. He also requested renderings of bike racks, floorplans, and courtyard access.
When asked about the proposed lobby bar, Gibson replied that it would be “an evening alcoholic one,” but ultimately “just an add-on.”
Public testimony continued to reflect sharp divisions.
Jake Thrasher, who lives one block from the site, disputed Kone’s portrayal of the neighborhood.
“It’s not dark and scary at all over here. I love my neighborhood,” he said. Thrasher warned the hotel would worsen congestion and walkability: “This project’s just gonna attract more of the public that’s gonna clog our streets and risk pedestrian safety.”
Speaking up in support of the hotel, Greater New Haven Chamber of Commerce representative Victoria Verderame called the proposal “a meaningful and strategic investment in our city’s economic future.” She emphasized that extended-stay guests “spend more time and money in our local economy. They frequent restaurants, support local businesses, and often become repeat visitors or long-term residents.”
Kone also pushed back against opposition from New Haven Rising, suggesting the criticisms were politically motivated given the group’s affiliation with the UNITE HERE unions, which represent Yale’s blue-collar and clerical workers as well as hotel workers at the Omni and the Graduate. She stressed that the development team had carefully followed all procedures, met with local officials including Alder Douglass, and ensured the application met all zoning and site plan requirements. In her view, the project was legally sound, and further delays were unwarranted.
During deliberations, Commissioner Joy Gary asked city staff whether the zoning concerns raised during the hearing changed their recommendation. City Plan Director Laura Brown replied that, despite the objections, staff stood by their conclusion that the application was zoning-compliant. She reiterated that the recommendation was based on the classification of the café as a restaurant.
While acknowledging lingering questions — particularly regarding the state Liquor Commission’s role in confirming permit eligibility — Brown affirmed her support for the original staff report.
City Plan staffer Castro acknowledged the concern raised by Kone that the restaurant could not legally have more seats than the on-site parking allows.
“Thirty-one parking spaces would be enough for a 124-seat restaurant,” he said. “That’s clearly not what’s happening here.” That is, the restaurant is likely to have less than 124 seats.
He noted that while the developer’s plans include an illustrative seating arrangement, it is not binding, as seating can change over time. Nevertheless, Castro concluded that “in our reading of the zoning ordinance, and in our review of this application, it is zoning compliant.”
The final site plan approval passed with three commissioners — Leslie Radcliffe, Joshua Van Hoesen, and Joy Gary — in favor and one commissioner, Adam Marchand, voting no. Marchand cited unresolved concerns about the layout and separation of the café and hotel, as well as questions about parking requirements and liquor license eligibility.
With those conditions in place, the city gave the green light to a project that has stirred both neighborhood anxieties and downtown economic hopes.

