41.5 F
New Haven
Monday, November 16, 2026
- Advertisement -spot_img

Overreporting? How about False Reporting!

Scandal of the CT police fabricating nearly 26K motorist tickets since 2014
by Sebastian Ward, Intern/correspondent,The Inner-City News


On July 19th, Governor Ned Lamont announced that he would be hiring a private firm to investigate the scandal of the CT police fabricating nearly 26K motorist tickets since 2014. This was in the wake of an audit released this past month, which was prompted by Hearst Connecticut Media releasing an article in 2022. The article uncovered 4 officers in 2018 reporting made-up infractions to receive better performance evaluations, granting them perks like shift preferences, new vehicles, and promotions. An internal investigation corroborated these claims, which resulted in two of the police officers receiving short suspensions, with the other two retiring before any disciplinary actions could be taken. No charges have been pressed to date, despite the internal investigation finding the four police officers guilty of violating three Connecticut State Police (CSP) administrative policies and forgery in the second degree.
The audit, which was being investigated by the Connecticut Racial Profiling Prohibition Project advisory board since last August, found that the number of falsified tickets “can be as large as 58,553 and as small as 25,966”. According to the report, there is a “high likelihood that at least 25,966 traffic stop records in the racial profiling database are false.” However, this is a conservative estimate. It continues to state that the investigation “allowed for extremely loose matching criteria and the number of false records is likely larger than we confidently identified.”
The report distinguishes two types of falsified tickets; The first type, which was what the Hearst article focused on, is referred to as “overreporting”. Overreporting is when a police officer creates a fake infraction and reports it to the Connecticut State Police, but not the not Centralized Infractions Bureau (CIB). Whenever an infraction is reported to the Connecticut State Police, it is automatically entered into the racial profiling database. The audit found that these types of falsified tickets were “more likely to be White non-Hispanic relative to minority”.
The second type is referred to as “underreporting”, where infractions within the CIB database did not have a corresponding record in the racial profiling database. Certain types of vehicle stops, such as commercial stops, do not prompt the completion of racial profiling information. This would explain why some records in the CIB database do not have a corresponding record in the racial profiling one. However, this does not hold true for all of them. The audit states that most of the 16,000 underreported infractions “should have necessitated the completion of a racial profiling record as part of the Alvin. W. Penn Act.” These infractions, which did not get reported to the racial profiling database, were more likely to be people of color.
The audit’s finding claims that it is extremely probable that the number of falsified tickets since 2014 has had a “substantive and statistically significant impact” on data and statistics related to the proportion of minorities stopped and racial profiling data as a whole.
The main takeaway from this audit is that many agents of the state who claim to fight for “law and order” have deliberately broken the law in order to appear more useful than they actually are, and, in the process, have significantly impacted racial profiling statistics, making it appear that a larger proportion of white motorists are pulled over than is actually the case. Equally important, however, is our governor announcing that a private firm will be further investigating this scandal. It demonstrates that our state leaders believe that the police cannot be trusted to investigate themselves internally and hold themselves accountable. The lack of any meaningful punishment for these police officers despite deliberate wrongdoing designed solely for purposeful enrichment, would suggest that our state leaders are absolutely correct in such analyses. So, this brings us back to questions which millions were posing during the BLM and George Floyd protests: Why are the police receiving so much funding if they need to lie to seem useful? Why are they incapable of holding themselves accountable? Who actually controls the police, and whose interests do they protect? Most importantly, why is there a special, extremely powerful and coercive force that is seemingly exempt from consequences, whose power is not checked by the communities they police?
The police force should not be a special, armed, entity attached to the government apparatus that stands above society. The police force is made up of people, and the only difference between them and everyone else is that they have been legally sanctioned to use violence to protect the interests of the state. They should be entirely subject to the citizenry, not the elite ruling class. We should have a democratic committee that is represented solely by elected community members with a mandate to oversee the police force, both in terms of activities and discipline. The members should have full access to police records, be empowered to revoke a police’s certification at any time, and have the ability to democratically pass any police reforms they agree would benefit the larger community. This is the only way to prevent scandals like these from occurring in the future.
Sebastian Ward will be interning with ICN through the Summer. Sebastian, a New Haven native and currently a rising sophomore at Yale University, has spent the bulk of his high school career engaging in community organizing efforts in New Haven.


Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Latest

National

Related news

Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading