40.5 F
New Haven
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
- Advertisement -spot_img

Judge Clears Way For 112 Apartments

by Thomas Breen The New Haven independent

A state judge has rejected two Lyon Street neighbors’ attempt to overturn the site plan approval of a proposed 112-unit apartment building on Grand Avenue, after finding that the City Plan Commission acted legally and appropriately when applying New Haven’s density-boosting inclusionary zoning (IZ) rules to this project.

State Superior Court Judge Kevin Shea handed down that ruling Wednesday, as detailed in a 31-page memorandum of decision in the case Linda Reeder v. New Haven City Plan Commission.

His decision marks a major victory for the New York-based developer looking to build 112 new apartments at a string of blighted, vacant commercial buildings at 873, 887, and 897 Grand Ave., including the former home of Unger’s Flooring. It also marks a setback for two neighbors concerned about a six-story development popping up near their backyards.

The ruling does so by upholding the City Plan Commission’s November 2023 approval of the site plan for that project — and by turning down a December 2023 challenge by Linda Reeder and Richard Tortora, who live nearby on Lyon Street.

The neighbors had warned that this new building, at a proposed height of 72 feet, would dwarf nearby two- and three-story residential buildings and cast a shadow over neighboring properties. They also accused the commission of misapplying New Haven’s IZ ordinance. That 2022 law requires certain new apartment buildings to set aside a percentage of rentals at below-market rates. The law also allows housing developers to build bigger, denser projects than would otherwise be allowed in a given zoning district in exchange for complying with these affordability rules.

Ultimately, Shea found that the commission’s site plan approval should stand, and that the commission was in the right in how it applied IZ and its associated density bonuses.

“For the reasons set forth below, the court finds that City Plan did not act illegally, arbitrarily, in abuse of its discretion, or without substantial evidence,” Shea wrote towards the beginning of his decision, ​“and therefore denies the plaintiffs’ appeal and sustains City Plan’s approval.”

His decision comes nearly three years after developer Joel Strulovich spent $3.1 million buying the derelict Grand Avenue properties with plans to replace the existing structures with a six-story residential building. The City Plan Commission in November 2023 approved Strulovich’s plan to build a garage on the ground floor and a total of 112 apartments on the next five stories. Of those units, 15 percent would be affordable to people making 50 percent of the Area Median Income (AMI), Strulovich said. (That currently translates to an annual income of $45,500 for a family of two.)

This is ​“great news, great news,” Strulovich said in a Friday phone interview. He said he’s still interested in building ​“a beautiful project” at this site. The next step, now that the judge has sided in his and the City Plan Commission’s favor, is ​“taking down the ugly building and making the city nicer.” He said he will be moving forward with this project ​“as soon as possible.”

In a separate email comment Friday, Reeder said she hasn’t yet read the judge’s decision, but she is ​“disappointed in the outcome.”

“I wish the developer had proposed an appropriately-scaled building, that the City had enforced the underlying zoning, and that when the Commissioners reached their decisions, they had had all the testimony for 24 hours and understood that IZ is an overlay zone giving them more discretion than they believed they had,” she wrote. ​“Given that the development abuts two-story homes on shallow lots and the narrowness of Grand Avenue, I think six stories is too high. I am an architect and can think in three dimensions. Four stories would have gotten no argument from me.”

Reeder added that, while she and Tortora were the only two named plaintiffs in this case, ​“we were the tip of the spear — more than a dozen neighbors contributed to the legal fees, and many more were opposed to the proposed development. We do not oppose all development, and we have no problem with affordable housing. But we want responsible, appropriate development.”

Reeder concluded by accusing the developer of ​“weaponiz[ing] blight by letting their property fall into disrepair” in this case. She also questioned whether or not building more market-rate apartments actually reduces overall rent in an area, rather than just attracting ​“more affluent people to move to enjoy the city amenities.”

Reeder did not say if she plans on appealing Judge Shea’s decision. Local attorney Marjorie Shansky, who represented Reeder and Tortora in this case, also did not respond to a request for comment about whether or not she and her clients plan to appeal. 

Strulovich’s lawyer in the case, Ken Rozich, declined to comment on the ​“pending matter.”

Meanwhile, local attorney Ben Trachten — who represented Strulovich’s company before the City Plan Commission for the site plan application, but who was not involved in this court case — heralded the judge’s decision. He said it helps ​“set the stage” for future IZ projects in the core and strong markets, which generally correspond to downtown and downtown-adjacent neighborhoods. 

“I’m excited to see inclusionary development across New Haven,” he continued, ​“and particularly the strong market and the core market, where we haven’t seen much development.”

The blighted, boarded-up building at 887 Grand.

In Wednesday’s decision, the judge rejected several IZ-specific critiques by the Lyon Street neighbors. He found that the applicant’s traffic study was sufficient and that the project is not legally required to have electric car charging stations.

He also weighed in on the Floor Area Ratio (FAR) requirements and IZ-provided bonuses governing the density of a proposed residential development at this site. (FAR essentially determines how tall a building can be, by defining the relationship between a proposed building’s total floor area and the size of the underlying property’s lot.)

Shea noted that the IZ ordinance allows for applicable developments to benefit from a FAR bonus ​“of up to 25 percent over the permitted FAR in the underlying zone in which the property is located.” According to the language of the ordinance itself, that bonus ​“may be otherwise limited by height restrictions and other bulk area requirements of the underlying zone.” 

Shea wrote that the proposed building would be located in a BA (General Business) zoning district, therefore allowing for a maximum FAR of 65,620 square feet. With the IZ-supported FAR bonus, he said, the building can actually have a maximum FAR of 82,025 square feet.

“Although the plaintiffs and other neighbors from the RM‑2 [High-Middle Density] zoning district voiced their objections to the building height at the public hearing and through written testimonies … the entire building is located within the BA zoning district, with no part of the building located in the RM‑2 zoning district,” the judge wrote. He noted that there are no direct height restrictions in the BA zoning district, ​“and the record is absent of any reference to any other bulk area requirement that might further limit the proposed building.” (The RM‑2 zone, which immediately abuts this section of Grand Avenue and which includes Lyon Street, has a height limit of four stories or an average height of 45 feet.)

“Whether or not City Plan had the discretion to limit the FAR bonus,” Shea continued, ​“the plain language of § 50 (d) (1) provided it with the discretion to approve the Application with the 25 percent bonus allowed.”

Therefore, he concluded, the commission did not abuse its discretion or otherwise act illegally or arbitrarily in this matter.

The plaintiffs also accused the applicant of failing to comply with the IZ ordinance’s affordability provision because the developer did not include specific income and rental limits in the site plan application. 

The relevant city law, however, states that a certain number of units in an IZ-compliant building must be set aside for households with a combined total annual income of no more than 50 percent AMI ​“at the time of initial occupancy,” Shea wrote. 

Therefore, he continued, ​“the court finds that the income and rental limits ​‘as required’ for the IZ Affordable Units are to be determined at the time of initial occupancy based on New Haven Area Median Income as defined by HUD at that time. It does not appear to serve any useful purpose to specify these limits in the application, which — as here — may occur years before initial occupancy, and the conditional approval guarantees that there will be compliance at that time.”

Finally, Shea noted that the plaintiffs claimed that the City Plan Commission applied the IZ ordinance to the relevant property ​“as a floating zone rather than an overlay zone as required, and that it is therefore illegal as applied.” (An overlay zone is a land use designation ​“where a specific additional requirement is imposed for the approval of a use otherwise allowed in the zone as a permitted use” and would be reviewed administratively, while a floating zone is ​“a special detailed use district of undetermined location in which the proposed kind, size and form of structures must be preapproved” and would be approved legislatively.)

Shea wrote that, in the commission’s application of the IZ ordinance, ​“all the requirements of the underlying zones continue to apply to the land within it, plus the additional requirements unique to the IZO.” He wrote that the plaintiffs’ arguments are really about IZ being a ​“regulatory jumble in general,” as opposed to any specific alleged violations by this particular project.

He repeated that there are no height restrictions in the BA district, and there do not appear to be any other bulk area requirements that would limit the the size of the proposed building.

“The court therefore finds that City Plan did not apply the IZO illegally in approving the Application.”

A rendering of the proposed new Grand Ave. apartment building, as presented at a November 2023 City Plan Commission meeting.


Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Latest

National

Related news

Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading