BY ADELE HAEG
Pallbearer Willie Darden at Thursday’s ceremony.
Mourners outside of Trinity Temple Church on Dixwell.
Edwin Gonzalez wore a shirt with a prom photo of Caraballo’s printed on the front to his funeral.
Teachers, classmates, friends and family of Malaki Caraballo gathered at Trinity Temple Church on Dixwell Avenue Thursday morning for the 18-year-old New Haven Academy student’s funeral — ten days after he was shot and killed in a double homicide in the East Shore.
Many in attendance at Thursday’s funeral wore black-and-red basketball jerseys bearing a picture of Caraballo, the number 23, and the words “Forever Melo” on the front and “Basketball Legend” on the back.
Speakers at Caraballo’s funeral included Police Chief David Zannelli, Pastor John Lewis, Mayor Justin Elicker, city Youth Service Bureau manager Ernie Cloman, Bishop Charles Brewer, and Rev. Robert Smith. They showed support for the many young people in the audience as well as their parents, and they asked for change.
“I see a lot of young people in this room, a lot of young men,” Elicker said during his remarks. “We’ve been to too many funerals. We do the same thing over and over and over. We go to the hospital, put on the t-shirts, we send up the balloons, we go to the wake, we go to the funeral. And then we decide to pick up a gun and seek revenge.”
Friends and family shared their memories of Caraballo with the audience during Thursday’s service. “He wasn’t even just my cousin, he was my brother,” said his cousin Narieh Jones, reflecting on the “laid back moments” she’d miss having with Caraballo. “He was such a funny person to be around, and he would lighten up your whole day, just by saying one joke.”
Caraballo’s aunt Shatoya Morris read aloud a letter that Caraballo’s younger brother Nasir wrote to him. That letter was also printed in the program. “Eighteen years was not enough, and I wish we had more time together,” Morris read, “just one more conversation, one more laugh, one more hug.”
Click here to read Caraballo’s full obituary.
The killings of Caraballo, better known as “Melo,” and 21-year-old Ansonia resident Jayden Martinez at the Fort Hale Gardens condo complex on June 22 marked the city’s first homicides since November 2025.
“There was a moment in time here, this year, that we were hopeful we were going a year without losing anybody from the city. And it felt like it was becoming a real possibility,” Zannelli said during Thursday’s ceremony, “and then this happened. And we were reminded that there was much more coming. This I promise you: We will find out the truth about what happened to Melo.”
An investigation into Caraballo’s killing is ongoing, according to city police spokesperson Officer Christian Bruckhart. Police previously stated that the fatal shootings were not random, and that they appeared to have taken place between two separate groups of men who knew each other.
Others who spoke at Thursday’s service talked about how cyclical gun violence has become, even as progress has been made in recent months. The funeral was held in the same Dixwell Avenue church as Daily Jackson’s less than two years ago; Jackson, a 17-year-old Riverside Academy student, was shot and killed in Newhallville in December 2024.
“We call upon the guardians who are carrying the unbearable burden of raising children in the middle of a war that’s in the streets,” Lewis said from the pulpit, images and videos of Caraballo rotating on a slideshow behind him. “We call upon every organization, every outreach worker, every violence interrupter, every counselor, and every advocate who have made it their mission to stand in the gap between life and death on these streets. Let your resolve not grow weary.”
Lewis reminded the audience of the city’s resources, including Project Longevity, a gun-violence prevention program. After the funeral, he remarked that the responsibility for keeping children and teens safe from gun violence falls on parents, but also on young people themselves — “we can’t do it without them,” he said. He wore clergy garments in red, one of Caraballo’s two favorite colors, along with black.
A few of Caraballo’s mentors, including Cloman and Smith, spoke to his character. Smith met Caraballo when he was seven years old, he said. “He was the cutest little guy,” Smith remembered. “He had all the courage in the world and he was the only kid that I noticed was truly scared of nobody.”
Caraballo’s high school teacher, Fana Hickinson, recalled how much joy he brought into the classroom. When he got his SAT scores back, “he jumped out of his seat and ran through the hallway screaming. And that was the end of the period. We were not going to be able to do anything else because Melo was so proud of himself,” she said. “NHA [New Haven Academy] is truly going to miss him.”
Cloman also praised Caraballo as a student. “Even in his turn for not so great, he respected us enough to not be around us, if that makes sense. Because he did not want us to see him be bad,” Cloman said. “It hurts really bad to be in this situation.”
Caraballo’s favorite colors were red and black, and according to his family, he had impeccable style.

