by Mona Mahadevan The New Haven independent
A $3.6 million construction project is reportedly underway at the blighted site of a former furniture store – 22 years after the Church of Scientology bought the property and eight months after the city approved the most recent iteration of the church’s renovation plans.
That’s the latest with 949 Whalley Ave., a .67-acre lot that sits across the road from office space rented by Connecticut Scientologists.
An unnamed member from the Church of Scientology’s Media Relations Team confirmed via email that “exploratory demolition” has commenced.
“We are currently carrying out exploratory demolition to identify every aspect of the building that needs to be repaired, reinforced, and restored,” said the statement. “Once this phase is completed, we intend to move forward with the complete renovation and restoration of the property.”
(Scientology is a modern belief system founded by science fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard and popularized by Hollywood celebrities like Tom Cruise and John Travolta. The church has drawn sharp criticism in investigative reporting, including a widely cited piece by by Lawrence Wright, and is often described as aggressive and litigious for its response to such scrutiny.)
Blue fences and a construction trailer were first spotted at 949 Whalley Ave. on Wednesday.

Originally constructed as a Masonic temple in 1930, the three-story building last served as the home of Hallock’s furniture store. The Church of Scientology’s Connecticut branch purchased the property for $1.5 million back in 2003, and the building has sat vacant ever since.
The church received approval to convert the building into a “community meeting space” in late 2018 but never followed through with the renovations.
The approval for those plans theoretically expired in November 2023, though a technical provision in Chapter 124 of the Connecticut General Statutes might protect the application through 2032.

That point is moot, in any case, because the church filed for two new permits in mid-2024: one in April for exploratory demolition and another in June for an “arrest the decline” package.
The first was approved by the city’s Building Department in June 2024 and allows for “select exploratory demolition to the existing building to uncover specific areas for structural analysis, further informing the extent of the primary demolition scope of work.” It also “serves as a preliminary package for the commencement of the full core and shell package.”
The second permit, which is for that “core and shell project,” was approved six months later. It allows the following: “a complete gut-rehabilitation of the building,” excluding its 1930s-era wood staircase and decorative mill work; removal and rebuilding of the third-floor auditorium ceiling; repair or reconstruction of areas with water damage; replacement of roofing and an adjacent addition; and repair of “existing masonry facades.”
The December 2024 permit further notes that new windows and doors can be installed in the building, as well as an elevator. It also permits “the stabilization of the 1950s addition” and the provision of new plumbing, mechanical, and electrical systems.
Narrative sections included in both permit applications describe the church’s high-level construction plans: “The original wood grand stair in the 1930 Masonic temple is to be repaired and restored. Some salvaged decorative elements will be repurposed within the new layout. Most of the interiors will be demolished due to water damage.”
The 1950s addition, the application notes,“has no decorative elements to retain” and has suffered “extensive water damage throughout the space.”
Construction is expected to cost $3.6 million, according to the December permit.
In a statement emailed to the Independent, a Church of Scientology spokesperson emphasized the group’s intention to respect and preserve the building’s historic character:
“Our renovation of the future New Haven Church of Scientology is a deeply respectful undertaking, centered around the preservation and enhancement of the historic 1926 Westville Masonic Temple. Guided by extensive research, we are meticulously restoring key architectural elements, including the original facades, entryway and iconic central stairway.”
“We are particularly focused on bringing back the building’s rich history, demonstrated by the planned restoration of the original 1926 brickwork and the careful replication of details like the building’s bronze work and classic light fixtures.”
The spokesperson added that the project aims to transform 949 Whalley Ave. into an Ideal Church of Scientology. Pioneered by the church’s current leader, David Miscavige, Ideal Churches represent “the physical embodiment of Scientology technology” and act as a full-service center for parishioners and local community members.
No timeline was provided for the renovation.
Exploratory demolition began about a year after the city revoked the property’s tax-exempt status, citing lack of progress in converting the building into a space of worship.
While the Church of Scientology has a long history of fighting with the tax man, its Connecticut branch has kept up with local tax bills on the Whalley Avenue property.
It paid its 2023 taxes in two equal installments of $39,871.18, and for 2024, the church paid half of its $81,606.46 bill in July. The remainder is due Jan. 1.
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



