by Laura Glesby
Mayor Justin Elicker: “The inequality is palpable” when it comes to school buildings; new jobs will help. Credit: Laura Glesby Photo Posted inSchools
Mayor Justin Elicker and Schools Supt. Madeline Negrón announced a $1.35 million proposal on Monday to build out an in-house facilities team for New Haven Public Schools.
The announcement came weeks after the school district officially severed ties with ABM Industry Groups, the private company it had contracted to manage school facilities.
Elicker and Negrón are proposing 19 new full-time positions and 20 new seasonal positions, all in charge of managing, maintaining, repairing and replacing school facilities under a new organizational structure.
Elicker has requested Board of Alders approval for a $1,348,710 budget transfer to fund the new positions for the remainder of the current fiscal year. For a full fiscal year, the new jobs are estimated to cost a total of $2,189,000.
The funding would come from a “salary reserve” in the city budget, a pool of money saved for potential salary bumps resulting from union negotiations. The mayor and alders originally allocated $6,136,131 to that salary reserve in the current city budget.
Elicker and Negrón announced the staff expansion plan at a press conference at Truman School on Monday afternoon.
They presented plans to hire six property managers, 25 seasonal and full-time groundskeepers, several specialized in-house technicians (including two HVAC technicians) and a handful of additional managers and administrators.
Facilities Org ChartDownload Proposed Organizational Chart
Elicker said he envisions that if alders approve the new positions, the city will need time to work with unions to draft new job descriptions and post the open positions. “We’re hoping that early on next calendar year, we can have some of these positions up and rolling,” he said.
He pointed to the six property manager positions and the HVAC technicians as some of the most urgent roles to fill.
Proposed New PositionsDownload Breakdown of Proposed Positions
Elicker pitched these jobs not only as a means of expanding the school district’s custodial capacity, but to expand supervision, accountability and grant-application capacity across the school district.
For example, each school building is supposed to have a building manager and an assistant building manager who oversee day-to-day maintenance and custodial work.
At the moment, Elicker said, all 39 building managers report to a single person. He and Negrón hope to create six new property manager positions, with each property manager responsible for overseeing building managers at six or seven school buildings. The property managers would work full-time in their designated buildings, not in the school district’s central office.
“You can’t be an expert in 39 schools. You can be an expert in six to seven of them,” said City Engineer Giovanni Zinn, who helped craft the plan.
“I’ve seen firsthand that there needs to be more capacity in public schools to apply for more grants,” added Elicker. The additional supervisors will form a new organizational structure that he said would provide “a clearer process for workflow, responsibility and accountability.”
According to Negrón, in addition to ongoing roof and HVAC projects at Truman School, Wilbur Cross High School, and Hillhouse High School, the district plans to apply for grants to replace or repair roofs at Sound School, Fair Haven School and Betsy Ross School.
“This is just a start,” said Negrón. “We are a district that has been underfunded.”
“Once this plan for staffing is in place, we will, of course, have further work to do,” she said, “to ensure that our school system has the budgetary resources it needs to address our many remaining capital infrastructure needs, as well as to establish the program of regular maintenance we will require for sustainable school building facilities going forward.”
In other words, more staff will need to be supplemented by more resources to fund the tools and materials needed to address maintenance concerns.
Alder Hogan: “This Is A Good Start”
The announcement comes weeks after the school district’s contract with ABM concluded on Sept. 30. In late August, the district had hired an in-house director of facilities who stayed in the job for a total of two days. Since then, Chief of School Operations Dr. Paul Whyte has been serving as the lead coordinator of facilities concerns.
Meanwhile, pressure has been mounting on school district leaders to address longstanding concerns in school buildings, including malfunctioning temperature control, mold, leaks and infestations.
The Board of Alders Education Committee and the New Haven Federation of Teachers have been leading voices, alongside students and staff, in advocating for an urgent plan to address hazardous or uncomfortable learning conditions across many school buildings. On Oct. 9, the Education Committee published a set of 16 demands of the school district, including a request for an organizational flow-chart outlining the chain of accountability for school fixes.
The Education Committee had requested that New Haven Public Schools (NHPS) produce a public dashboard outlining the status of every work order at every school. Asked about this request, Whyte said that the school district is working to create such a dashboard.
Referring to the alders, Negrón said, “We are hopeful that their expressed concerns about the safety and well-being of our students and staff — the one that you, all of you, have been covering for weeks — will actually translate for the support that we’re going to need from them.”
Beaver Hills Alder and Education Committee Chair Gary Hogan said that he had not seen a concrete version of the plan as of Monday afternoon. Still, he expressed support for the overall concept of funding new staff positions to tackle school maintenance.
“One of the things that the committee and I have always agreed upon is that it’s gonna take money, staff and materials to get this done,” Hogan said. “This is a good start for the board of ed and the city to collaborate and put together some funds to increase the number of staff.”
Ongoing Vacancies, “Palpable” Inequality
Supt. Negrón, Mayor Elicker, City Engineer Zinn, and Chief of School Operations Whyte were joined by Board of Education members OrLando Yarbrough and Abie Benitez as well as Hill Alders Evelyn Rodriguez and Kampton Singh.
On Monday, school and city leaders traced the compounding facilities concerns to longterm funding insufficiencies at NHPS compared to school districts in more wealthy and white towns.
“I think everyone can agree that our students need safe, clean, beautiful facilities to learn in, and facilities impacts our students’ learning,” said Elicker. “And everyone also agrees that our schools have been underfunded for decades.”
He noted that New Haven spends about $1.70 per square foot on school maintenance. “Industry standard is $3 to $4.50 per square foot,” he said.
“Our suburban partners spend almost double what we do per square foot in our schools,” said Elicker. “And that is clearly unequal. The inequality is palpable.”
While the city is proposing to add new positions, vacancies remain among the school-based building managers in charge of maintenance at their designated building. At the start of the school year, 17 of the 39 building manager positions were vacant.
The school district is in the process of filling those vacancies, but the process is complicated, according to Whyte. Whyte said that a union agreement requires the school system to fill those vacancies via an internal bidding process, so NHPS has to first hire “floater” custodians eligible to bid for those openings rather than directly hiring new building managers.
Since the beginning of the school year, according to NHPS spokesperson Justin Harmon, 14 people have been offered positions as custodial “floaters” and 10 of those people have completed pre-employment requirements — leaving 3 vacancies left to fill. Whyte said that Hillhouse High School, one of the schools with the most severe facilities concerns, does not currently have a building manager.

