by Paul Bass
After the mayoral election votes are counted next week, New York may have something to learn from New Haven, and vice versa.
One of the candidates on the ballot, New Haven Mayor Justin Elicker, offered that perspective, about non-police emergency response teams and about free buses, during a conversation Tuesday about his quest for a fourth two-year term. The conversation took place on an episode of WNHH FM’s “Dateline New Haven” program.
Democrat Elicker faces Republican challenger Steve Orosco. (Click here and here to watch and read about a previous campaign conversation with Orosco and here and here for write-ups about the Elicker-Orosco campaign debate.)
In this campaign, Elicker has pursued a clear compass about the city’s direction the past six years: He has emphasized his administration’s record on creating new affordable housing, overseeing a decline in crime rates, and suing the Trump administration three times to free up withheld federal funds.
He has also touted his administration’s creation of a non-police emergency response team — Elm City COMPASS (Compassionate Allies Serving our Streets) — to handle 911 calls about nonviolent incidents involving people experiencing mental health crises or problems involving homelessness or substance abuse. One concern the program addresses is that law enforcement presence can potentially escalate some situations that would otherwise remain calm in the hands of trained social workers.
Meanwhile, a top issue in New York City’s mayoral race is Democratic candidate Zohran Mamdani’s call to create a similar non-emergency team to free up cops to handle other crimes rather than try to serve as social workers. Mamdani’s opponents criticize the idea, as do some cops, who call it unrealistic or soft on crime.
New Haven heard some of those concerns from cops when it created COMPASS, Elicker recalled.
Over time, the officers came to embrace the concept, including phoning in requests for COMPASS assistance.
The city helped gain their acceptance by at first not having 911 operators directly contact COMPASS. Rather, officers would make the decision at the scene about whether to call in COMPASS. Now that acceptance has settled in, 911 operators are directly contacting COMPASS and freeing up officers for other work, Elicker said.
“We spent a lot of time talking with [cops and firefighters] about the program, testing it out some, and I think the officers realized that it’s actually an incredible tool for them,” Elicker said. The city also learned it needed to expand COMPASS’s staffing and hours of operation.
Elicker was asked if he has advice for New Yorkers concerned about Mamdani’s following in New Haven’s COMPASS footsteps.
“It’s a good thing for the police. It’s a good thing for the community. Honestly, it surprised me that New York hasn’t done this already,” Elicker replied.
Mamdani has also vowed to make riding New York’s public buses free. Asked about that, Elicker said he’d like to see CT Transit, which runs New Haven’s buses, do the same. He noted that temporary fare-free rides instituted during the Covid-19 pandemic boosted ridership and seemed to work well. (Click here to read a previous interview with New Haven State Rep. Roland Lemar about why he’s not pursuing that idea.)
Also in the “Dateline” interview, Elicker said:
• His administration is working with nonprofits who feed the poor to help make meals available if food stamp (SNAP) benefits disappear next week because of the federal government shutdown.
• His administration right now is focusing on working in the courts as the primary strategy to fight the Trump administration’s withholding of environmental, security, and other aid based on sometimes vague ideological dictates about race and climate and immigration. He was asked how the city will decide between losing, say, education or security or environmental funds or signing on to federal dictates that contradict the city’s values. “I think we got to cross that bridge when we come to it. We’re going to fight tooth and nail up until that point, and we’re hoping we’re not going to arrive at that point,” he said.
• His administration is working with the Board of Alders to change the details of the city’s Inclusionary Zoning (IZ) plan, which requires developers to include affordable units in new market-rate apartment projects. No such units have been built since the law took effect in 2022. Elicker said he doesn’t believe the problem lies with the concept itself, but rather with the details, in part because of changes in construction costs.
• New Haven does not have a donor in the wings ready to fund his plan to turn English Station’s waterfront property into a park with a public outdoor swimming pool, the way a private donor funded a similar project in Norwalk. He did say he may pursue private donations for the project as part of the cost of creating the park.
• New apartments are filling up fast as the city’s housing boom continues. Newcomers filling those apartments are often young adults or empty-nesters, he said. He noted that the city’s public school population has declined as the city’s population at large has increased. He said he’s keeping his eye on that trend and looking into the reasons. He said he feels the schools have made progress since problems that arose during the pandemic, while more work remains to be done.
Click on the video at the top of this story to watch the full conversation with Mayor Justin Elicker on “Dateline New Haven.” Click here to subscribe or here to listen to other episodes of “Dateline New Haven.”

COMPASS outreach worker Famatta Gibson connected Ronnie to emergency shelter two summers ago, during a state crackdown against sleeping in Union Station. Credit: Nora Grace-Flood File Photo

Elicker with the Democracy Fund’s Sarah Ficca and Aaron Goode outside the mayoral campaign debate. Paul Bass Photo
Discover more from InnerCity News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



