by Coral Aponte CTNewsJunkie
Senate Majority Leader Bob Duff, D-Norwalk, testifies on behalf of a bill to prevent book banning during the Children’s Committee public hearing on Thursday, Feb. 13, 2025, at the Legislative Office Building in Hartford. Credit: Screengrab / CT-N
HARTFORD, CT – The General Assembly’s Committee on Children heard public hearing testimony Thursday on a bill to prevent book banning in Connecticut.
Senate Majority Leader Bob Duff, D-Norwalk, spoke in support of the legislation, Senate Bill 1271, and sat for questions from committee members.
“It is of the utmost importance that all perspectives, beliefs, and ideas be accessible through books,” Duff said. “Often, it is books addressing issues related to race, gender identity, and sexuality that are banned. In Connecticut alone in 2023, there were 113 challenges against books in our libraries. Proponents of banning books use the excuse of protecting children from lewd material, but this is a cover to ban freedom of thought, endangering tolerance and weakening democracy. That is why I have received a multitude of emails of support from librarians and parents from around the state and around the country.”
SB 1271 would prohibit school or public libraries from censoring or excluding books due to their origin, authors, background, or view of the material. It would require public libraries and local school boards to create policies for book curation and removal, including a way to address concerns. Duff said the bill would provide school librarians and staff members with protections from criminal and civil liability.
Along with his support, Duff requested a revision to extend the protections from criminal and civil liability to public libraries and their staff as well, including a request to add language to “grant school and public librarians and library staff members with a civil cause of action for emotional distress, defamation, liable, slander, damage to reputation, and any other relevant tort against any person who harasses a librarian or library staff member for confiding with state law.”
Duff also asked the committee to include a prohibition on public and school libraries from excluding or censoring books because a person finds such books offensive.
During the public hearing, members of the committee had questions regarding obscene or egregious material found in books and children’s access to them.
Rep. Ceci Maher, a Wilton Democrat who co-chairs the committee, asked Duff if he thought children being exposed to pornography was okay. Duff responded by saying this is not an issue in libraries.
“If you think that some child is going to the library to get porn, I got a bridge to sell you, because they can get that on their phone much faster than they can ever get it at their library,” Duff said.
Rep. Gale Mastrofrancesco, R-Wolcott, asks a question about a bill that would prohibit book banning during the Children’s Committee public hearing on Thursday, Feb. 13, 2025, at the Legislative Office Building in Hartford. Credit: Screengrab / CT-N
Rep. Gale Mastrofrancesco, R-Wolcott, had the same concern and asked Duff if he thought there should be language in the bill that would prohibit pornography being made accessible to youth.
Duff explained that we have librarians for that very reason – to make sure that students and kids are getting age-appropriate books.
“This is why you have librarians, school librarians, who are trained. They are trained in what is age-appropriate for children. That’s why you have boards of education and that’s why you have superintendents,” Duff said.
Rep. Anne Dauphinais, R-Killingly, disagreed, stating that a librarian’s degree or training may not qualify them to decide what is right or wrong for their children.
Dauphinais said she was concerned about parents not having oversight of their children in schools where they can be exposed to obscene material. Dauphiniais asked almost every person testifying on the bill whether they thought child pornography, or depictions of obscene or sexual material, should be available to students and kids.
Duff responded that it seems they’re putting unnecessary language into the debate because the problem doesn’t exist. He also said that there may be books that someone deems unfit for their child, but others might feel differently. He said he was not concerned about the egregious material because librarians are there to ensure material is age-appropriate, but he said book bans limit creativity and perspectives.
“Most books that have been challenged as lewd or pornographic in reality involve African American history, LGBTQ issues, and racism,” Duff said.
In the 2023-24 school year, over 10,000 books were banned in public schools elsewhere in the US, with many of them being young adult books and books with LGBTQ+ characters or racial themes, according to PEN America.
“Book banning is an antithesis to freedom of speech,” Duff said, adding that if legislators are working to help children, they should look at setting parameters on phones and apps, or at making sure children can eat every day, that they have healthcare, housing, and enough money in schools to close achievement gaps.
Throughout the hearing, Mastrofrancesco stated that opponents of the bill were not there to ban books, but rather to protect children from graphic material in schools.
Duff said SB 1271 would still allow parents to voice opinions on books and provides a process for that. He said some schools may already have processes in place and if not there is under SB 1271 because it would allow people to critically think and have freedom of thought for conversations over such books.
Aside from allowing a system in which parents can effectively address concerns and protect books from being banned, the legislation would also protect librarians.
Duff said the bill is meant to prevent harassment and bullying that librarians have been seeing.
Speaking in support of the legislation, Connecticut Library Association President Scott Jarzombek said he has seen firsthand the kind of harassment librarians face.
In his oral testimony during the public hearing, he recalled one instance where he had to put himself between one of his staff members and another individual to prevent violence. He said his job had been threatened and he had received negative and harassing messages.
Jarzombek said he has no problem hearing parents’ concerns but that there needs to be a safer way to do that.
“Many of us in the library field are not opposed to book challenges; there is no other institution that welcomes public feedback like public libraries. What we seek and what this bill provides is a clear, rational way to hear honest concerns from parents,” Jarzombek said.

