42.4 F
New Haven
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
- Advertisement -spot_img

City Sues Insurer Over Wrongful-Conviction Coverage

by Thomas Breen

The Elicker administration has sued a Missouri insurance company for not paying a larger portion of the city’s $30.5 million wrongful-conviction settlements with Marquis Jackson and Vernon Horn.

The city filed that lawsuit in Connecticut federal court on Nov. 13.

The lawsuit accuses Westport Insurance Corporation of failing to provide coverage and insurance benefits to the city for certain policies that were in effect between July 1999 and August 2003.

In particular, the city argues that Westport Insurance has agreed to pay only $5 million pursuant to insurance coverage the city had in place in 1998. The city claims that Westport should pay more thanks to policies that were in place in 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, and 2003 while Horn and Jackson were incarcerated.

Click here to read the lawsuit.

The lawsuit focuses on a pair of recently approved settlements between the city and Horn and Jackson, each of whom spent nearly two decades in prison after being convicted of a 1999 murder. Their convictions were eventually overturned on the grounds that city police had fabricated evidence and withheld potentially exculpatory evidence. Upon securing their freedom, each man sued the city — Horn in 2018, Jackson in 2019.

In August of this year, Mayor Justin Elicker announced that the city had settled those two lawsuits for $15.25 million each, or $30.5 million in total.

Elicker said in August that the insurance coverage that the city had in place at the timeof the police misconduct would pay $5 million plus attorney’s fees, while the city would be on the hook for the remaining $25.5 million. In October, the alders agreed to let the city borrow $27 million to cover its portion of the settlement payments.

This newly filed lawsuit shows that the Elicker administration is trying to get Westport to pay more than the already-agreed-to $5 million, based on policies that the city had with the company — as successor to Coregis Insurance Company — between 1998 and 2003.

“While the mayoral administration at the time this incident took place in 1999 did not sufficiently insure the city for wrongful incarceration settlements, we want to ensure the city is appropriately reimbursed based on the insurance coverage it had at the time,” city Corporation Counsel Allison Jacobs told the Independent in a statement.

“While the insurance company has agreed to extend a certain amount of coverage (approximately $5 million plus attorneys’ fees), the city believes it is owed additional coverage under our policy.

“We had hoped to resolve this when we settled with the plaintiffs, but given the insurance company’s unwillingness to comply with the terms of our contract, we are taking this matter to court.”

Westport could not be reached for comment by the publication time of this article.

The city’s lawsuit states that Westport has agreed to defend and indemnify the city only under the 1998 policy it issued to New Haven, and not under the 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, and 2003 policies it issued to the city.

The Elicker administration claims that Westport needs to cover a portion of the settlement payments under the 1999-2003 policies because those policies included Public Entity Excess Law Enforcement Liability Coverage and Public Entity General Liability Coverage. That coverage ensured that Westport would pay for “bodily injury” and “personal injury” claims arising out of wrongful arrest, detention, or imprisonment; “malicious prosecution”; and violation of civil rights.

The lawsuit argues that Horn and Jackson have claimed that they incurred exactly those types of injuries during their wrongful incarceration when the relevant policies were in effect between 1999 and 2003, as well as afterwards. Those injuries stemmed from “inadequate medical treatment” and “loss of freedom and liberty.”

The lawsuit states that the insurance company agreed to contribute “a certain sum of money towards a portion” of the newly announced Horn and Jackson settlements, but refused to pay the balance to indemnify the city under the subsequent Westport policies. “As a result, Plaintiff was forced to pay a significant portion” of the two settlements “from its own resources.”

The city thereby accuses Westport of breach of contract for the 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, and 2003 policies issued to the city in relation to the Horn and Jackson settlements.

The city is seeking monetary damages, pre-judgment interest, post-judgment interests, costs, and other relief from the court.

This lawsuit comes after the city recently agreed to pay Adam Carmon $16.5 million to settle another wrongful-conviction case. It also comes after a federal jury in Hartford awarded Stefon Morant $38 million in still another wrongful-conviction case that the city had taken to trial. (The city is appealing the Morant decision.)


Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Latest

National

Related news

Discover more from InnerCity News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading