Site icon InnerCity News

Beloved CT restaurant was forced to close. Here’s what longtime customers are doing to save it.

Kevin Heyward owned Kevin’s Seafood in New Haven for nearly 50 years. (Courtesy of Heyward family)

By Sean Krofssik | skrofssik@courant.com

Kevin Heyward opened Kevin’s Seafood in New Haven 1976 as a teenager and, after nearly 50 years in the city, he was forced to close the restaurant in 2025 due to multiple health problems.

With former workers and customers offering their support, Heyward’s family has launched a GoFundMe in the hopes to offsetting his growing medical bills since closing the business at 17 Kimberly Ave. in New Haven last November.

Heyward said it was a difficult decision to close.

“I had just so many (medical) bills that had to be paid and things that just needed to be dealt with,” he said. “It just got to the point where I couldn’t pay my help. Prices of the products had gotten crazy, and I just overextended myself to a point where I couldn’t do it anymore.”

Top Videos Introducing Nutella Peanut, the company’s first new flavor in more than 60 years

Heyward had a heart attack a few years ago and recently dealt with a variety of health problems including a long bout with COVID and pneumonia.

“There’s just so many things. I’m working on trying to figure out why I’ve lost so much weight. I’m not quite sure. The doctors are trying to do different tests to see why I’m losing weight. I’ve just been dealing with ongoing health issues,” Heyward said.

Since closing, Heyward has been stopped around New Haven asking if the restaurant is opening again. He said he has been blown away by the outpouring of support from former workers and customers.

“Closing was pretty devastating,” Heyward said. “I get so many people that stop me any place I go asking me if we are going to reopen. I went to a restaurant about two weeks ago, and a woman approached me and my daughter. She told me that she and her mother had been going to the restaurant since she was little and insisted on paying for my meal. It struck me about the impact we had in the community.

“I have some health issues that are concerning me and I’m not bringing in any cash. Things get pretty tough and that’s where we are today,” Heyward said.

Courtesy of Heyward family

Kevin’s Seafood was a staple in New Haven for almost five decades. Owner Kevin Heyward was forced to close in November 2025 due to health issues and rising medical bills. (Courtesy of Heyward family)

The GoFundMe campaign started on March 14 and has raised over $4,300 as of Wednesday afternoon.

“This is my life. I will be 70 next month. I put my body through a lot over the years, working all the hours I was working and all. I would love to be able to open up at some point, but right now, most importantly is just being able to survive every day, eat and live,” Heyward said.

Heyward said he was always happy to help sports leagues and church groups with fundraisers over the years running his business. He would also provide fresh meals to people he saw trying to get scraps out of his dumpster. However, he was reluctant to ask for help, because he didn’t want to come across as begging people for something but eventually relented.

“The outpouring has been great,” Heyward said.

“It’s been a challenging time for the family,” said his wife, Cheryl Heyward. “This has been his whole life. This is all he’s ever known. I’m just trying to be supportive to him and if the opportunity presented itself, we would open back up. Since we have closed, it’s been nice to know what this restaurant has meant to people.”

In 2021, Kevin Heyward even received a proclamation from the city of New Haven celebrating 45 years of Kevin’s Seafood and honoring him for his service and support in the community.

“Kevin’s Seafood has been a pillar in the community for so long. We would love to have that open again someday,” Cheryl Heyward said.

According to Cheryl Heyward, the money the family receives will go to medical bills.

“It’s been several months now, and he’s got some uncovered medical expenses that have presented themselves and I put in the GoFundMe to get over the hump,” she said. “His health is the No. 1 priority.”

Courtesy of Heyward family

Kevin Heyward prepares fish at Kevin’s Seafood. The family is hoping to raise money to help with medical bills through a GoFundMe. (Courtesy of Heyward family)

New Haven native Dennis Jarman said he has known Heyward since he was selling fish as a teenager in the mid-1970s at the original Kevin’s Seafood, which was located at 716 Dixwell Ave. for 25 years.

“I moved to Washington, D.C. and Kevin became even bigger and he moved to Kimberly Avenue. When I would come back to town, this was my go-to spot. (He had) seven or eight different kinds of fish. He had the whole belly clams. He had shrimp. And our scallops,” Jarman said.

“Kevin is an institution in the New Haven area similar to Sally’s or Pepe’s,” he added. “When somebody’s looking for fish, Kevin’s Seafood is the place to go.”

Kevin Heyward said the biggest seller in his restaurant was “Kevin’s Filet Sandwiches.”

“People would rave about our sandwiches, our box of fish, shrimp and our onion rings we would make ourselves,” Heyward said. “I would pack the sandwiches so big they would ask if they could buy more bread to make another sandwich.”

Rev. Curtis Antrum, pastor of Abundant Harvest Outreach in New Haven, has known Heyward for 30 years.

“I had fish there all of the time,” Antrum said. “It’s a staple on a Friday or Saturday at least three times a month or more. It’s just how it was.

“Kevin is a community guy,” he added. “He’s bigger than life. He has a certain quality. I know first-hand his fish is quality and there’s a certain taste and he always gave you enough. There’s nothing else in the area that can compete with Kevin for seafood. … There’s no replacing it. When it closed, it felt like something died.”

Antrum said he is happy to see the community rallying around the Heyward family with the hopes the business will open again.

“Knowing Kevin, I believe this is not the last of what we’ve heard from him,” Antrum said.

Exit mobile version