by Adam Walker The New Haven independent
East Rock/Fair Haven Tanbee Caroline Smith leads tour.
What if a dim, noisy highway underpass could become a safe route to school, a community park, and a public performance space — all at once?
That’s the vision East Rock/Fair Haven Alder Caroline Tanbee Smith still has for the underpass beneath Interstate 91 near State and Willow streets. Thanks to a recently awarded $17,500 grant, that vision is moving closer to reality.
That money comes courtesy of an AARP Community Challenge Grant. The effort to revitalize the underpass is part of the Mill River Underpass Project.
The project aims to gather input from youth and neighbors to help design and build a community park alongside the future Mill River Trail — beneath I‑91 at State and James streets, directly behind the Ralph Walker Hockey Rink at 1080 State St.
During a Thursday morning tour of the site, Smith led a small group — including AARP Connecticut members Barbara Munck and Valerie Ferrebee, civic advocate Ben Berkowitz, Arts Council Director Hope Chávez, and lifelong New Havener Charlie Nixon — through what she hopes will soon become a reimagined public space. With sketchpads, stories, and a fresh round of funding in hand, they’re planning the next phase of a transformation that’s equal parts youth-led design project and neighborhood safety intervention.
“This idea of reimagining the space has kind of been in the community and in the ether for a long time,” Smith told the Independent. “It was around last spring or early summer that we really tried to accelerate it — to give it life, make it an initiative that could bring people together.”
The idea gained momentum last summer when Smith and collaborators recruited over 30 high school students — many of them from Fair Haven, walking daily to Wilbur Cross High School — to form a youth design team. The group has since helped shape plans for the underpass, aiming to make it both a safer route to school and a gathering space for students and neighbors alike.
“We asked ourselves: ‘Can this be a safe place for students to walk through — and also to spend time after school?’” Smith said. “We wanted young people’s perspectives to be a pillar of the planning process.”
The newly awarded AARP grant will help fund two next steps: additional community engagement and formal architectural renderings. An upcoming public design session is scheduled for Aug. 6 at 6 p.m., right under the underpass. Smith said they also plan to host targeted focus groups with seniors, families, child care centers, and more high school students, including creative “activations” like live music to test the site’s acoustics and artistic potential.
The second half of the grant will pay for architectural renderings of the site, alongside a potential logo or name —“a kind of identity” for the space, as Smith put it. She hopes to have a draft plan ready by the end of December, which will then be presented to the Connecticut Department of Transportation, which owns the land.
Berkowitz, a skateboarder and former Upper State Street Association president, has been an early champion of the project — both as a civic innovator and longtime friend of Smith. He helped bring in Olympic skateboarder and architect Alexis Sablone to consult on the space’s design, drawing on their unique ability to blend public art, sport, and urban renewal. Berkowitz previously played a key role in building the Edgewood Skatepark and co-founded SeeClickFix, a civic tech platform.
According to Smith, he was the first person she called when the idea was reignited last year. “He’s the one I texted and said, ‘Remember that idea we’ve been kicking around all these years? Let’s try to make it happen,’” she said.
Nixon, a longtime New Haven resident who remembers the construction of I‑91, reflected fondly on his time growing up in the neighborhood — living on Humphrey Street, fishing along the Mill River, watching baseball games at Blake Field, and grabbing fried dough from the local pizza truck. So when he heard about the Mill River Underpass Project, he knew he had to get involved.
“Ever since my childhood, I have always had a love for this whole area,” Nixon said.
Chávez and the Arts Council of Greater New Haven have partnered with Smith as fiscal sponsors and connectors to a regional artist network, helping bring creative flair to community planning.
Smith added that advisory members such as Fair Haven resident Ana Juárez, a board member of Elm City Compass, and Erick Gonzalez, former director of the Grand Avenue Special Services District, are helping shape the process to ensure it remains inclusive and responsive to community needs.
At the tour, Chávez reflected on the artistic possibilities the underpass offers — from lighting installations to public art and performance. She noted that the Arts Council is building a robust artist database and hopes to activate the space in ways that are both unexpected and inclusive. Chávez described the space as having the potential to be more than just a path — it could be a place to gather, perform, and play.
“There’s so much you can do with lighting that doesn’t have to be permanent,” Chávez said. “There’s a lot you can do with these concrete structures that can become something whole that can make it feel whole.”
For Smith, it’s about making something beautiful, useful, and rooted in New Haven.
“A lot of students walk back and forth over Willow Street, which is really hot, very uncomfortable, and not the safest,” Smith said. “The hope is that this space can be an alternative — something more beautiful, safer, and something they feel a sense of ownership over.”
Hope Chávez, Valerie Ferrebee, Barbara Munck, Charlie Nixon, Caroline Tanbee Smith, Ben Berkowitz, David Hunter

